Pin the saxaphone on Squidward
Spongebob Pinata (our local party supply place has them premade)
Musical chairs with spongebob songs - they have his greatest hits on CD, or if you're near a computer just make a youtube playlist of the different songs
Krabby Patty eating contest - use the fried tuna fritters you make with crushed saltines on a bun, make them eat blindfolded or hands behind their back, etc.
And now that I realize I came up with this many ideas in all of 2 minutes, I think it's time to ban Spongebob around here for a while!
at 2:52 AM on Nov. 2, 2009