How about some of those "coupon" things for couples? You know, like "IOU a massage" or "For one day, I'll do whatever you like" and that sort of thing. They're fun, low cost, and they don't say "OMG! I'm like SOOOO psyched that you're my boyfriend and I'm looking forward to being at your side every second until we die!" in a really creepy way lol. Or something like a day in bed, complete with meals and adult fun ;-) Or make him has favorite meal, favorite dessert, buy his favorite drink, then take him to the bedroom when you're done. If you want something that's a little "romantic" also, throw in a card or a short (very short, not several pages long lol) poem or something telling him how much you enjoy being near him, and stuff like that. I'm bad with gifts lol. If you want a "real" gift, maybe get him one of his favorite shows on DVD.
at 2:00 AM on Nov. 10, 2010