Join the Meeting Place for Moms!
Talk to other moms, share advice, and have fun!

(minimum 6 characters)

3 Bumps

Racial Bias lawsuit in Philly. Do you agree it is racism?

PHILADELPHIA (AP) — Four white Philadelphia teachers filed federal race-bias lawsuits that accuse a black principal of creating a hostile work environment and suggesting they were unfit to teach black children.

The teachers work at a predominantly black elementary school that has a recent history of racial tension. Their lawsuits say that a former principal had them read an article that said “white teachers do not have the ability to teach African-American students.”

The teachers also allege that the principal, Charles Ray III, and others undermined their work by reprimanding them, randomly changing their room assignments and letting black teachers ignore rules that their white counterparts had to follow. Ray also retaliated when they filed union grievances, they said.

“Charles Ray III consistently stated that he had a relationship with top school officials indicating that his conduct was part of an approved policy or was part of a pattern of practices sanctioned and supported by ‘higher authority,”’ the suits allege.

The teachers—Nicole Boyd, Debra McKibben Marenbach, Colleen Yarnell and Marta Ciccimaro—filed the lawsuits last week, demanding more than $150,000 each. Courthouse News Service first reported on the complaints Tuesday.

The school district had no immediate comment, spokeswoman Shana Kemp told The Associated Press.

Kemp said she was not immediately authorized to say if Ray still works for the district. A message left at a possible home number for him was not immediately returned.

Racial tensions among staff at Thomas Mifflin Elementary School have simmered before.

A white principal left about four years ago amid a chorus of complaints from black parents. One mother testified at a City Council meeting in December 2007 that she had heard the administrator say Muslim students looked like “flying nuns,” according to news reports.

In April 2008, vandals defaced a mural on the side of the school with anti-Semitic graffiti.

Ray arrived that fall, and lasted only for the 2008-09 school year, the lawsuit said.

The surrounding East Falls neighborhood is largely white and, in some sections, wealthy. Residents include former Gov. Ed Rendell and former U.S. Sen. Arlen Specter. But many white families in the area send their children to private schools.

Mifflin currently has about 270 students, 86 percent of them black and 85 percent of them poor, according to school district data.

The defendants include the local teachers union and a supervising teacher whom Ray allegedly ordered to go through personnel files and investigate their home and personal lives.

Lawyers for the teachers did not immediately return calls for comment.

Answer Question

Asked by Carpy at 10:45 AM on May. 18, 2011 in Politics & Current Events

Level 39 (114,053 Credits)
Answers (22)
  • yeah...i think the principal was definitely prejudice towards those teachers if all those accusations are true.

    Answer by samurai_chica at 10:56 AM on May. 18, 2011

  • If the accusations are true then yes.

    Answer by chaiteamomma at 11:01 AM on May. 18, 2011

  • Sounds like the guy has a major chip on his shoulder. I find most racists are not white so if this is true it doesn't surprise me.

    Answer by itsmesteph11 at 11:18 AM on May. 18, 2011

  • I'd hardly be surprised if it were true.Racism doesn't only come from some whites towards blacks.Things change and this did many years ago.

    Answer by tnmomofive at 11:27 AM on May. 18, 2011

  • The four teachers who filed lawsuits also accused principal Charles Ray III of giving them poor performance reviews because they're white.

    And although he accommodated black teachers with "physical limitations," he refused to do the same for Debra McKibben Marenbach, a 12-year teaching veteran, who was reassigned to the second floor even though she couldn't climb the stairs.

    As retaliation for complaining, the suits say, Ray ordered teacher Shirl Ishmael to "secretly" investigate the white teachers and gave her access to their personnel files.

    The suit goes on to say that Ray then released their personal information, including their home addresses, to an investigator he hired to "intimidate, harass and find basis for firing [Marenbach] and other white teachers."


    Answer by SuperChicken at 11:39 AM on May. 18, 2011

  • SuperChicken

    Answer by SuperChicken at 11:39 AM on May. 18, 2011

  • Wow. Way to lead by example.


    Answer by QuinnMae at 12:03 PM on May. 18, 2011

  • I would like to see the article referenced I know there has been a couple of studies done that state African American students do better with African American teachers..... Is that what it was stating?

    Also I am assumming that there where more then just these four white teachers.... Did the others get the same treatment?

    If not it could be an issue with him and those particular teachers vs all white teachers.


    Answer by Charis76 at 12:06 PM on May. 18, 2011

  • Wow. So if what the article he was referring to is true...then black teachers shouldn't be teaching white children...does this mean we should segregate again? I think it is outrageous and if true he is a true racist and this is true racism. That is really sad..he is supposed to be a role model.

    Answer by yourspecialkid at 12:11 PM on May. 18, 2011

  • Will be curious to see how this plays out in court....

    Answer by grlygrlz2 at 12:15 PM on May. 18, 2011

Join CafeMom now to contribute your answer and become part of our community. It's free and takes just a minute.