Big Kid Buzz

daily buzz >> Big Kid Buzz

Sight Words and the Pressure to Read

February 23, 2009 at 6:10 AM by Cafe Kierna - Comments (5)

sight words, readingKindergarten and first grade moms know this journey all too well. Five and 6-year-olds are deep in the throes of learning how to read, and along with that comes a remarkable amount of anxiety for us parents. The transition from simply reading to your child to expecting them to read back to you can be a bumpy ride.

"Sight words" undoubtedly become a major topic of conversation--and sometimes a major challenge. I know I certainly feel discouraged when my kindergartner reads words like "here, " "went," and "they" one week, and the next week doesn't remember them at all. Am I doing enough?  Should I be drilling him more? It doesn't help that I have my mother in my ear reminding me that if it's not fun for him, I will lose him altogether on the reading path. Yet nothing I do to make it fun seems to be enough fun to actually make him eager to work on his words. Sure, he'll do them, but not with much enthusiasm. Sometimes I worry I've already been to hard on him and now he's somewhat turned off.

Of course, that doesn't mean the pressure on me is turned off. I distinctly recall my son's teacher saying early on that these "sight words" are not necessarily words for him to sound out--they need to be memorized; he should know them on sight. But like I said, some weeks are just better than others. I don't feel relaxed at all about the need to get him reading--and thanks to CafeMom, I know I'm not alone.

My4kidds has a similar story that she shares in The CafeMom Newcomers Club: "I recently found out that my 1st grader is a little behind her class on the level of sight words she knows. I was pretty devastated because I thought she was doing well...She's very smart; just has trouble sitting still and concentrating. So, I wrote out all her sight words and put them on index cards and posted them on this door that is in a main area of the house so she will see them all the time, and made up a couple concentration type games to help her learn them," she says.

An anonymous mom revealed that her kindergartner has already come home with paperwork suggesting that her child be tested for learning disabilities because he doesn't know words like "like," what," to" and "you." She's a nervous wreck now questioning herself about whether or not the teacher sees something she doesn't, or if there is just too much pressure too soon.

I'm not quite sure that the issue is that there is too much pressure on the children at this age, because no matter what, they have to learn to read--and it's been proven that at 5 and 6, this is very doable. But my thing is, how awesome would if be teaching techniques for parents came with the mandate to get kids reading? In my opinion, well, certainly in my house, that's often where the breakdown is.

I did find some fantastic reading help tips from Mrs.Grasshopper who has a 6-year-old kindergartner. I just want to thank her so much! I love them and if you are in the process of teaching your child to read, I bet you'll love them too!

  • use clay or Play-doh to make long snakes and then make them into letters and make the sight words
  • using dry erase markers write them on glass, write the sight words on the mirror in the bathroom. She can read the words while she brushes her teeth or combs her hair
  • use the flash cards as "musical words." Tape them on the floor in a circle, play music, stop the music and ask her what the word is shes on
  • make a bingo game with the words
  • make a word search with the words
  • create the sight words using yarn, tooth picks, Q-tips, beans, macaroni, pipe cleaners, or Popsicle sticks.
  • write the words in salt or sugar in a deep cookie dish
  • try the same thing with jello or pudding
  • write them on a Magnidoodle
  • paint the words with water on a chalk board
  • write the words with glue, then sprinkle with jello, after it dries have her rub the words for a scratch and sniff practice
  • use a tape recorder to practice words
  • use scrabble board letters
  • use magnetic letters on your fridge
  • have her cut them out of a magazine or newspaper
  • use gel shave cream to make the words, let them dry.
  • use flash cards and place them inside shoes, pockets etc
  • put paper clips on each flash card then "fish" for them with a magnet hooked on a string

Is your child learning to read? Do you use sight words? Is it a struggle? Do you have creative techniques to share? Let's join hands on this one.

FILED UNDER: education, elementary school, homework

Comments:

mamap...

I have one child who was taught to "sound out" words, another who learned "sight words", and a third in kindergarten learning now.  Can you guess which one is the avid reader, the one who comprehends more of what she reads, and is most likely to properly pronounce a new word?  I don't like the "sight word" teaching method at all.  In my opinion, the traditional learning method of sounding out words builds a much stronger foundation for reading later in life.  I have taken in upon myself to implement "sounding out" with my youngest child. 

mamapotter Feb. 23, 2009 at 6:39 AM

amybu...

I do flash cards to keep him interested.  I carry them with me so when we are waiting for something, we learn.  Patience and consistency is the key for my kids.

amybuddy45 Feb. 23, 2009 at 7:31 AM

Jessy...

I think way too much is expected out of children so young.  They're not miniature adults and I think it's stupid to assume a child has a learning disability just because they don't know confusing words that aren't phonetical, like 'what', 'you', and 'like'.  To be honest it sounds like the teacher doesn't want to take the time to focus a bit more on that child and sending them to a resource type class makes so she doesn't have to.

That said, my 6 year old enjoys reading and sounds out words.  I will do the same with my 5 year old. 

Jessy0419 Feb. 23, 2009 at 9:22 AM

DawnA72

I don't like the sight word memorization method at all.  Understanding phonics and how to sound out words is important.  My first graders are already learning spelling rules which is helping immensely with their reading. 

We DO have a word wall, and it consists of all those words that cannot be sounded out and don't fit any of the spelling rules.

DawnA72 Feb. 24, 2009 at 9:33 PM

Bruce...
Please, don't you at least have to consider the option that Flesch was right all along? My own research convinces me that learning to read via sight words is very difficult. That's why the US has 50,000,000 functional illiterates. If you are interested in the other view, please Google my "37: Whole Word versus Phonics." Another article is "40: Sight Words -- The Big Stupid." I also have many graphic videos on YouTube that explain why Sight Words are a problem, e.g., "Why Sight Words Don't Work." Marva Collins said she taught (using phonics) all children to read in the first grade. With sight-words, a child is supposed to memorize a few hundred words each year, meaning no real literacy is achieved for many years.

Nonmember comment from Bruce D. Price Jul. 28, 2009 at 3:14 PM

Want to leave a comment and join the discussion?


Sign up for CafeMom and become a member. As a member you'll be able to leave comments, join groups, write journals, share photos, and more. Already a member? Click here to log in.

Or, leave a guest comment (guest comments are moderated and won't appear immediately)

Around CafeMom

Advertisement
Advertisement

© 2009 CMI Marketing, Inc. All rights reserved.