Big Kid Buzz

daily buzz >> Big Kid Buzz

The Only Child Myth

April 5, 2009 at 8:24 AM by Cafe Kierna - Comments (30)

only child, cow

People say all kinds of mean things about only children. Spoiled and selfish definitely come to mind. But an increasing amount of families are deciding to only have one child whether it be for financial reasons or otherwise. With reports surfacing about first-born children getting more attention and time--to the detriment of other sibs-- it seems there is a wisdom to having one child, perhaps one that only mothers of only children fully understand.

A couple of years ago, ABC's 20/20 did a report entitled "The Only Child Myth" that not only busted the stereotypes about only children but also shed light on something else:

"While a battery of studies shows no difference with onlies when it comes to bossiness or acting spoiled, it turns out there is a significant difference when it comes to intelligence. A landmark 20-year study showed that increased one-on-one parenting produces higher education levels, higher test scores and higher levels of achievement."

I have to bear witness and say that all of the only children I know are especially smart. (And maybe just a wee bit selfish. LOL!)

If you have an only child, be sure to join the private group My One & Only: Moms to One Child.

Are you an only child? Is your child an only child? What made you decide to stop at one?

FILED UNDER: behavior

Comments:

mom2mads

My daughter is an only child, at least unless we get a miracle baby!  I never meant to have only one child that is what fate decided for me.  I am trying to focus on the positives for her, how she doesn't have to share us with anyone and can have more stuff because we will have more time attention for her.  I have to admit she is a wee bit spoiled but she is a sweet, loveable little girl and not a bit mean or nasty, her teacher's say she is friends with everyone and is so kind to each and every person she meets.  And I can also admit, that I, who am not an only child was #1 spoiled rotten and knew it #2 acted like an incredible brat my entire life #3 got in lots of fights at school, was selfish and downright nasty!  So my little only child so far has one up on me, the kid who grew up with a sibling and was awful!

mom2mads Apr. 5, 2009 at 9:20 AM

Beda1970

My son also is a only child,i was not married when i had him,i never expected to get pregnant so young much less being single.But he is the light of my life he makes me laugh and smile.And yes he is so smart A-B honer role all year,plus passed his first tasks test with flying colors.I am very proud of him and so what if i don't have more which is not a possibility since i had my tubes tied after he was born.,he is a very happy child and he gets more attention from me and my fiance because he is a only child.I grew up with three sisters so no wonder i was the quite on of the group!!!

Beda1970 Apr. 5, 2009 at 9:35 AM

pirat...

I was an only child until I was 13 yrs old, and I was A/B Honor Role student, Gifted and Talented, and all that good stuff.  I was a touch spoiled, and part of me really wants my daughter to be an only child, but dh wants a big family. 

piratesmermaid Apr. 5, 2009 at 1:00 PM

ladys...

Woot!!! I have an only child, shes 3. I want 1 more but hubby does not so I am thinking she might always be an only child and she is very smart. Thanks for giving me some good positive light about my only child. :)

And I hadnt heard of that group you mentioned but I recommend the group "Moms of Onlies" found here http://www.cafemom.com/group/7063

ladysylpher Apr. 5, 2009 at 1:05 PM

Cinna...

I am an only child and I can tell you that my mom and dad are my closest friends. I can and have always been very close to them, even during my rebellious years as a teen.

I wouldn't change it for anything. I am also very creative, and I have a great imagination (I had an imaginary brother when I was little). A one child family is a great family.

I was even sad for a while when I was pregnant for the second time, fearing that if I have another baby I wouldn't be as close to my precious first. Things have worked out fine for us, but there are times when my oldest misses out because I am busy with the youngest.

Having only one is a blessing that some people won't understand.

 

Cinnamon-mom Apr. 5, 2009 at 1:29 PM

momto...

My son is an only child and he is very smart.  Adults love to be around him because he can carry on a conversation with them.  He is not a brat at all.  He can be bossy but my sister has 4 kids and her oldest is bossy.  I hear a lot of negatives about only children but the only children I know are usually the most well behaved, intelligent and polite kids I know. 

I wanted more children but that was not meant to be we are content and happy with our only child. 

momtoonecuteboy Apr. 5, 2009 at 2:30 PM

Libra...

I am an only child and I swore I would kidnap a second child before I would let my son be an only! ( I ended up having quite a few kids!)

I HATE IT and I wish every day that I wasn't an only. My parents wanted so much for me and I tried to fill everyone's wishes. Dad wanted a scholar, Mom wanted a popular cheerleader, Dad wanted a buddy and so did mom. I felt guilty if I seemed closer to one than the other. This was of my own making; they didn't cause it.

Now I have no one to reminesce with about my childhod. Dad has been dead for 20 years and Mom is almost 80. There is no sister or brother to talk about funny memories.

And guess who is responsible for Mom? There is nobody but me and I am disabled.

My kids have no cousins, I have no nieces and nephews. I won't ever be "Aunt"

I an a loner and I think it is partly because I became used to being alone and now I prefer it.I became a book worm and still feel like my best friends were characters in books.

My parents did not want to have an only child - my dad's closest relative was an only child who died at 22 leaving his parents alone and devastated. This terrified them and they tried to have more.

We all have to make decisions for ourselves but I truly regret being an only.

LibraryLady200 Apr. 5, 2009 at 2:48 PM

Kenre

I have a cousin who grew up as an only child. She met her twin sister when we were in high school. Her twin, 6 hours older than her, has two younger brothers. They were like night and day. My only child cousin was shy, but selfish. She hated us who had siblings, because we usually had to bring the younger ones with us. She even refused to be with us sometimes, and would rub it into our faces when she got something new (a lot of times saying, "Too bad you're not an only child like me. My parents can afford this. Yours can't.)

Kenre Apr. 5, 2009 at 3:16 PM

offic...
I am an only child and my mom is an only child. I have no cousins, nieces, aunts, uncles, etc on my side. My hubby is the youngest of 4, so we have family gatherings on his side. As a child, I loved being an only child. However, now that I'm an adult, I really wish I had siblings! I would love to have someone to talk to about the past.
My husband and I had planned to only have one child, but the older I got, the more I wanted my son to have a sibling in his life. I have never regretted that decision!!

officefan01 Apr. 5, 2009 at 4:56 PM

Amand...

I do agree, a lot of the only children I know are very smart people!

However, as much as I sometimes wished I could have been an only, I'm glad I had a younger brother. Who else would you blame for knocking over the lamp or making a mess in the house? Haha... plus there is always a built in person to hang out and play with growing up. My SO wants our baby to be the only one, but we'll see how it goes after the first few years.

Amanda_Jeanne Apr. 5, 2009 at 5:26 PM

Want to leave a comment and join the discussion?


Sign up for CafeMom and become a member. As a member you'll be able to leave comments, join groups, write journals, share photos, and more. Already a member? Click here to log in.

Or, leave a guest comment (guest comments are moderated and won't appear immediately)

© 2009 CMI Marketing, Inc. All rights reserved.