I got this mascara and black Bad Gal waterproof liner. I usually love Benefit, but man I am so dissapointed! They both smudged and the mascara flaked... I was just a mess at the end of the day. I am so bummed, I liked how the mascara looked and the brush is good, but I wore it 3 days in a row and I just looked awful at the end of the day! So they are going back. They both get great reviews, I wish they had worked for me.