Join the Meeting Place for Moms!
Talk to other moms, share advice, and have fun!

(minimum 6 characters)

Homeschooling Moms Homeschooling Moms

Schools, Technology and Cancer Links. WWYD?

Posted by   + Show Post
I saw this this morning as I signed in. It has weighed on me and I just wondered, are we EVER going to understand things of this magnitude?


If my child was suddenly and unexplainably diagnosed with cancer and died 11 months later, I would be searching high and low for answers that may or may not exist. I would be so heartbroken that I wouldn't know where to turn, what to do with myself, or how to create a positive situation out of a heartbreaking, horrifying one. So I can't fault these parents from New Zealand for blaming the death of their 10-year-old son, who was diagnosed with brain cancer less than one year before he lost his battle with the disease, on their son's school's Wifi and iPad usage. But, in spite of some surprising coincidences that have been revealed, they may be taking things too far by fighting all schools in their district to get rid of technology.

When doctors found tumors on Ethan Wyman's brain, they told his parents they were about 3 months old. The young boy had been issued an iPad as part of his school's 1:1 education initiative 4 months prior to the doctors' discovery. Ethan's father says that, while he doesn't blame the school's technological advancements for causing his son's cancer, he can't help but feel like it's too big a coincidence to ignore.

Ethan's parents are making a big push to the school board to remove all iPads and Wifi connections from local schools. They reportedly have two children who still attend the school, which may explain why they feel passionately about this -- or maybe they are really just trying to do something they feel is positive in order to counter the awful event that very recently shattered their lives.

But the Wyman's may find themselves fighting an impossible battle. Both the New Zealand Ministry of Health and Ministry of Education find no link between Wifi and cancer. And, though we should remain skeptical since a few studies have found a possible link between cell phones and cancer, the majority claim tech is safe enough to use in schools.

We also shouldn't downplay the important role tech is occupying in schools. In this country, Common Core Learning Standards practically require that computers are incorporated into lessons. Students who use devices like iPads have access to a world of information that reaches far beyond their textbooks.

Given the lack of scientific proof here, it seems like the benefits of technology outweigh the possible harmful effects. I feel for these parents and understand why they are making this effort to change their schools, but I'm not sure this is the right battle to fight.

Do you think schools should get rid of technology because of a possible link to cancer?

  

undefined

by on Dec. 27, 2013 at 11:02 AM
Replies (21-22):
JKronrod
by Bronze Member on Dec. 28, 2013 at 5:18 PM
1 mom liked this

 The point is that you have to have facts that truly suggest at least a correlation.  As far as I can tell, we don't even have that in this case, let alone causation.  People's feelings (scared, concerned, or otherwise) about whether something is or is not causing something is not an appropriate standard. 

Quoting kirbymom: Okay. So, maybe scary isn't the "right" word. Maybe the more appropriate word should be "concerned".
In either case, this is something that should be watched and researched consistently, so as to be on too of any issues that may or may not arise.


Quoting JKronrod:

 If we avoided anything that anyone found potentially "scary," we'd still be hiding in caves wondering when the tiger was going to eat us.  "Scary," especially subjective "scary," is a really, really bad metric.


Quoting kirbymom: But it IS scary to think this is a possibility.



Quoting usmom3:

 I agree with this! We have WiFi in our house because the only internet we can get is through wireless so we have signals coming in & getting distributed to all the computers & devices all the time! We never turn off the router so it sends a signal 24-7. I also know we are not the only people to do that, library's, restaurants & book stores offer free wifi all the time!


I am sad for that family but I think they need to be looking else where for the answer!


Quoting debramommyof4: This is exactly how I feel.
Quoting hipmomto3:

If there truly was a link, wouldn't we be seeing an exponential increase in brain cancer rates over the last ten years? And wouldn't it be steadily increasing each year, as more public places provide wifi access, and more people spend time on phones and tablets? I haven't heard of any findings like that. It's very sad what happened to their son and I agree, I'd probably be searching for a solution anywhere I could, but I don't agree that the answer is to eliminate technology from schools.


 


 

 

kirbymom
by Sonja on Dec. 28, 2013 at 6:02 PM
1 mom liked this
Your right. One case isn't hundreds. However, based on research, past experiences and my gut instincts, I do think this type of "case" bears watching to see if there is a trend that is compiling up or that we are just not recognizing the signs.
Besides, it only takes one to make a precedent upon which others can build evidence from/for.


Quoting JKronrod:

 The point is that you have to have facts that truly suggest at least a correlation.  As far as I can tell, we don't even have that in this case, let alone causation.  People's feelings (scared, concerned, or otherwise) about whether something is or is not causing something is not an appropriate standard. 


Quoting kirbymom: Okay. So, maybe scary isn't the "right" word. Maybe the more appropriate word should be "concerned".In either case, this is something that should be watched and researched consistently, so as to be on too of any issues that may or may not arise.
Quoting JKronrod:

 If we avoided anything that anyone found potentially "scary," we'd still be hiding in caves wondering when the tiger was going to eat us.  "Scary," especially subjective "scary," is a really, really bad metric.


Quoting kirbymom: But it IS scary to think this is a possibility.



Quoting usmom3:

 I agree with this! We have WiFi in our house because the only internet we can get is through wireless so we have signals coming in & getting distributed to all the computers & devices all the time! We never turn off the router so it sends a signal 24-7. I also know we are not the only people to do that, library's, restaurants & book stores offer free wifi all the time!


I am sad for that family but I think they need to be looking else where for the answer!


Quoting debramommyof4: This is exactly how I feel.
Quoting hipmomto3:

If there truly was a link, wouldn't we be seeing an exponential increase in brain cancer rates over the last ten years? And wouldn't it be steadily increasing each year, as more public places provide wifi access, and more people spend time on phones and tablets? I haven't heard of any findings like that. It's very sad what happened to their son and I agree, I'd probably be searching for a solution anywhere I could, but I don't agree that the answer is to eliminate technology from schools.


 


 



 

Add your quick reply below:
You must be a member to reply to this post.
Join the Meeting Place for Moms!
Talk to other moms, share advice, and have fun!

(minimum 6 characters)

close Join now to connect to
other members!
Connect with Facebook or Sign Up Using Email

Already Joined? LOG IN