Thoughts?
Home birth advocate dies in home birth
AP
A nurse holds a baby girl, born only moments before, at a maternity hospital.
London - A passionate advocate of home births has died after her own home labour.
Australian campaigner Caroline Lovell, 36, went into cardiac arrest while giving birth to her second daughter, Zahra, at her home.
She was taken to hospital but died the next day. Her daughter survived.
The tragedy, in Melbourne on January 23, will re-ignite debate about the safety of home births.
NHS statistics show that between 2000 and 2008, home births in the UK soared by 54 percent.
Lovell had made arrangements for a private midwife to assist with the delivery, but unknown complications during the birth caused her heart to stop. By the time paramedics arrived at her home, she was critically ill.
The photographer, who leaves behind her husband Nick, her first daughter Lulu, three, and newborn Zahra, had lobbied the Australian government for more state support for women who wanted home births.
In 2009 she told a health inquiry that midwives who assisted with home births needed proper funding and legal protection, in line with other countries.
Her written submission warned that “lives will be in threat without proper midwifery assistance” from the state.
She wrote: “On a personal note, I am quite shocked and ashamed that homebirth will no longer be a woman’s free choice in low-risk pregnancies.
“As a homebirthing mother I will have no choice but to have an unassisted birth at home as this is the place I want to birth my children.”
Lovell had spoken of her excitement at her impending arrival.
On October 19, she posted a message on the Facebook site for her massage business that read: “Maternity leave officially started this morning... had a beautiful last night at work and will keep you all posted on my burgeoning growth as a mother to be - second time round.”
The Midwives in Private Practice group said it was the first time they had heard of a mother’s death following a home birth. A spokesman said: “It’s very, very rare.”
A senior midwife told the Mail that a severe haemorrhage was the most likely cause of death, but an inquest has yet to be held.
The Association for Improvements in the Maternity Services in the UK said the tragedy should not put expectant mothers off home births.
Chairman Beverley Lawrence Beech said: “While this is very sad, it is extremely rare - almost unheard of - for women to die during home births.
“Research clearly shows that home births in the UK are no more dangerous than hospital births.
“If anything, it is safer and you are much less likely to have unnecessary medical intervention.”
In the UK, women are provided with NHS midwives if they opt for a home birth.
But in Australia, women are discouraged from giving birth at home and expectant mothers must find a private midwife.
Lawrence Beech said the “medical mafia” in Australia should reconsider their stance and provide “adequate support” for mothers who choose home birth.
Beth Wilson, Health Services Commissioner for the Australian state of Victoria, said she had long held concerns about home births when medical back-up might not be immediately available.
“It’s very sad to hear about this and I know the coroner will conduct a full and thorough investigation,” she said.
Last night, friends paid tribute to Lovell.
One wrote: “This world will miss your beauty, your vibrance and your refreshingly honest and truthful way of living. What a beautiful woman. We will miss you.”
Another said: “Caroline was a beautiful being whose naturalness touched so many. She didn’t know she was special, but we did.
A story from the Daily Mail - 01-02-2012
HOME BIRTHS: THE FACTS
In England, about 1 baby in 50 is born at home and women are usually assisted through labour and birth by a professional such as a midwife.
Many women opt for home births because they prefer a relaxed, familiar environment and would rather avoid a hospital visit.
The safety of home births is a subject of frequent debate and many experts have called for a ban on the birthing technique.
They argue women who give birth outside of a clinical setting put themselves and their newborns at risk.
In many developed countries, home birth declined rapidly over the 20th century, for example in the U.S. home birth declined from 50 per cent in 1938 to fewer than 1 per cent in 1955.
According to the American Pregnancy Association the risks associated with at-home delivery include fetal distress, cord prolapse, hemorrhage and high blood pressure.
New data suggests home births have risen by 29 per cent in the U.S. triggered by the 'Hollywood influence', better safety measures and lower costs. - Daily Mail
I feel the same way. I would want to be in a birthing center or hospital in case something happened. I actually ended up needed a c-section because my son was stuck and couldn't pass through the birth canal. My heart goes out to her family.
Quoting sjump25:I don't feel one way or another about someone birthing at home. I wouldn't do it because I would be afraid something would happen and there not be any drs or medical equipment. That's just me though. I think this will not look good for the at home birthing community though :/
i think it is up to the person who does it. its not like they do not know that there will not be immediate medical attention in case something "goes wrong". but it is still a risk they are willing to take. Just like as a mom who had their kids in the hospital i knew that there was a risk of them pushing me to a c-section or telling me i needed one, that was a risk that i was willing to make.
i fully support anyone right to birth THEIR children as they see fit, and i dont think the government should be able to say yes or no. If the government DOES step in, there is going to be a lot of women doing it anyway without any assistance at all, and that is where things can get really dangerous!
i personally opted to have both of my children in the hospital because i had pregnancy complications. Multiple miscarriages, a calcified placenta, meconium, etc. So i personally felt more comfortable being there with medical staff, however, i understand why other people dont feel that way.
One death. Not that it isn't significant. It is a sad and tragic thing. But one death out of how many healthy homebirths? How many women die in the US from infections after c-sections? Shouldn't that be more of an issue?
This is terrible and I hope her family the best and loving care from here on. But because she "had" to do a UC in order to have a home birth. If the state were to support the expansion of midwives, certified and regulated, maybe this wouldn't have happened.
Quoting sjump25:
I don't feel one way or another about someone birthing at home. I wouldn't do it because I would be afraid something would happen and there not be any drs or medical equipment. That's just me though. I think this will not look good for the at home birthing community though :/
I agree. It's absolutely not for me. And the fact that it says in Australia they're not provided the same kind of midwife as in England (I think it meant they were less trained) which implies there was more of a risk would scare me even more.
The issue I have with home births is that if anything goes wrong emergency care can't easily be provided in a timely manner. I have a friend that works in a NICU and the stories of infants that end up there because their parents tried a home birth are enough to make me nay-say it all. I simply don't think that the risk is worth it; not the risk to the mother, and most definitely not the risk to the child. My own son was an emergency c-section and had we not been in the hospital it would have added an easy 20 mins to the process and that might have meant the life of my child... fuck that. The medical care exists and I believe in taking full advantage of it.
I think it's sad that they show this instead of others who did have medical interventions at hospitals and were critically ill or passed. I am all for homebirths and natural births, but I always get so nervous before I deliver. I would love to have as natural a birth as possible.
This is sad :( Home birth is awesome but you know what? You can have an amazing 'home birth' experience in the hospital, too! You can have a birthing pool and whatever else you want. Plus all of the staff and equipment is there just in case of an emergency exactly like this. Why would you put yourself in danger like this when there are so many other options? This could have been avoided... my prayers go out to her family..
Sadly not every hospital has natural birthing facilities. I don't even know of one near me and I am in CA. They don't allow babies to be birthed in pools they are only for labor btw.
Quoting EmmaGlenn20:This is sad :( Home birth is awesome but you know what? You can have an amazing 'home birth' experience in the hospital, too! You can have a birthing pool and whatever else you want. Plus all of the staff and equipment is there just in case of an emergency exactly like this. Why would you put yourself in danger like this when there are so many other options? This could have been avoided... my prayers go out to her family..
Blogging
- sjump25
on Feb. 2, 2012 at 11:24 AM