If a woman breaks an engagement should she return the ring?

[carolina_gal]

 Or do you consider it a gift she can keep?

[Christy644]

 i think it depends on the break up.

he cheats-hell no keep that thing!

but if it;s a mutaul we just arent ready then yeah

[bhwrn1]

She should return it

[angelachristine]

speaking as someone who once broke an engagement it never once crossed my mind to keep the ring. I think it would have been wrong.

[Blueskyes]

Yes, I think its the right thing to do and in some states, possibly the law.

[websorceress]

I think it depends on how long she's had it, I also think who breaks it off makes a difference.....I do agree with the heirloom thing, the ring should stay in the proper family.........

[.MhacFoirfe.]

No way! She should give it back! If he breaks it, then sure, she should keep it if she wants.

[shygirl.sk]

I think it should be returned....Ive never understood the concept of holding onto an engagement once you decide not to marry. I think the only exception would be if you had a child together. Perhaps when they were of age-it would be something you want to pass along to them.

[BeachMommy07]

 I would return it.

[eustacejessica]

I think the ring should be returned

[Kaci]

 If it belonged to mom or gm or is a family heirloom I would return it. If your not going to wear it, return it. Other than that, keep it.