The Santa Lie: Is the big Christmas con hurting our kids? What do you think?
Illustration by Alex Eben Meyer.
We raise our kids to be truthful. We teach them about the laws of physics. And then we tell them that nine flying reindeer pull an immortal fat man and his sleigh through the sky so that he can deliver gifts to millions of kids around the world one night a year.
Is it bad that we lie to our kids about Santa?
Though lying can be an awfully convenient parenting crutch—Sorry, sweetheart, but the police might arrest you if I let you have more candy so we better not—it’s generally best to keep it to a minimum, both to develop trust between yourself and your child and to lead by example. Except in December. Because guess what? Not only is the Santa myth harmless, but it might actually be good for kids’ cognitive development. Fantastical stories foster a type of imaginative play that sparks creativity, social understanding and even—strange as it may sound—scientific reasoning.
First: Let go of any guilt you have about duping your kids. Santa belongs in the “good lie” pile because parents invoke him for their kids’ sake; bad lies are the ones parents use to deflect blame or avoid responsibility—we can’t go to the playground today because it’s closed,when really, you’re just too lazy to get off the couch. By the time children learn the truth about Santa Claus (which is usually by age 8, according to Jacqueline Woolley, a psychologist at the University of Texas at Austin), they typically understand the difference between these types of lies, so they don’t resent their folks or suddenly think that across-the-board lying is OK. (For that matter, kids also do not reject religion, develop post-traumatic stress disorder or become drug addicts after learning that Santa is not real, as one fiercely anti-Santa websiteclaims.)
What Kris Kringle does do is feed the imagination. Kids picture him managing his elves at the North Pole, soaring through the sky or squeezing through chimneys. Sometimes children participate in the fantasy themselves, adopting the role of Rudolph or Mrs. Claus in games with their friends. These forms of play may cultivate a set of skills known as “theory of mind,” which helps kids predict and understand other people’s behavior. (Children with emotional disorders such as autism typically have theory of mind problems.)
For example, a 1997 study by University of Oregon psychologist Marjorie Taylor, author ofImaginary Companions and the Children Who Create Them, found that, regardless of their intelligence, 4-year-olds who frequently engage in fantasy play are also better able than other kids to distinguish appearances from reality (they know that a pink rabbit held behind a color filter is still pink), understand other people’s expectations (they know people will assume that a crayon box contains crayons, even if the box actually contains a small toy) and know that perceptions depend on context (they know people will identify images differently depending on how much of them they see). Taylor’s more recent work suggests that preschool and school-aged kids who lead rich fantasy lives—for instance those who have imaginary friends—have a better understanding of emotions, too. (That said, it’s impossible to say at this point that play improves theory of mind skills, because it’s possible that children who frequently engage in imaginary play also happen to be those with a more developed theory of mind.)
Photo by Samir Hussein/Getty Images for Selfridges.
Fantasy play also forces kids to think through hypothetical or counterfactual scenarios, which bolsters their reasoning skills. What will happen if the elves don’t finish by Christmas Eve? What would Christmas be like if Santa didn’t exist? Research by Alison Gopnik, a psychologist at UC-Berkeley and author of The Philosophical Baby: What Children’s Minds Tell Us About Love, Truth and the Meaning of Life, suggests that this kind of thinking helps children develop models of how the world works and forces them to reason in a causal, rational fashion. This thinking can also help kids envision creative solutions to problems or come up with new ideas. After all, before someone can effect change or design something new, he or she has to be able to see the world differently.
Pretend play and fantasy can also be therapeutic for kids going through tough times. In a 2006study, researchers asked 35 children living in sheltered camps during the end of the second Israel-Lebanon war to “look after” a stuffed animal for three weeks. Thirty-nine other children in the camp did not get stuffed animals. After the war, the researchers interviewed all the parents and found that the kids who had adopted the animals—and especially those who cared for the animals most intensely—experienced fewer stress-related problems such as nightmares and separation anxiety than did the other children.
Obviously, kids can and do engage in pretend play even if they don’t believe in Santa—he’s by no means a necessity for healthy development. And sometimes, parents use Santa inappropriately, such as when they force their terrified kids to sit on Santa’s lap or when they use him primarily as a disciplinary threat—If you keep throwing pens at your sister, Santa will leave coal in your stocking. But none of the experts I spoke with worry that Old St. Nick, however mismanaged, will cause kids lasting psychological damage.
It’s even possible to teach kids the truth about Santa in a positive way: just give them the tools to figure it out for themselves, Woolley says. If they ask you point blank, does Santa really exist? answer with questions of your own—What do you think? Are you starting to think he doesn’t? Why? Then—because if they’re inquiring, they’re probably ready to learn the truth—start outing the lie. Write a letter from Santa in your own handwriting or hide the stocking stuffers in a slightly too-obvious place. That way, any pain your child feels over losing Santa will be softened by a sense of pride: You can’t pull one over on me anymore! Except maybe with the tooth fairy.
In addition to the sources mentioned, The Kids thanks Alan Kazdin from Yale University, Michael Brody from the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, Lawrence Balter from New York University and Robert Feldman from the University of Massachusetts.
.....Ophelia Grace...............Mira Lorne...............Jude Bennett.........Liam Daniel Baines.