Mix the peanut butter and jelly in a bowl before I make the sandwiches. I have always done this even as a kid. I think it tastes better. I will even eat it out of the bowl like that if I don't feel like eating a sandwich. I have tried that Goober crap and that is just what it was..... crap. I didn't realize this was so abnormal. Is it, though? Does anybody else do this? Or am I the lone person in ALL OF THE WORLD that mixes their peanut butter and jelly together?

Cream cheese and jelly??!!

Quoting mom2aspclboy:Actually, that makes sense to me, but I don't eat PB&J because don't really care for peanut butter. I do love cream cheese & jelly, though, and mixing the two before putting them on the sandwich sounds like a good idea. I'm going to try it the next time I make myself a cream cheese & jelly sandwich.
I don't mix it in a bowl-why dirty a dish? But, I always spread the peanut butter, then put the jelly on top of the peanut butter and swirl it together. Otherwise, I don't like the jam right on the bread-honey is worse.
no but I dnt like pb&j sammies nor do my kids lol we usually have peanutbutter crackers, with ritz crackers an jiff pb lol
My DD2 dipped her peaches in ketchup once. I was so grossed out. LOL. She seemed to like it though :/
Quoting loveTHEviking:It's not weird :). I caught my 5yo dipping a pb&j in his lemonade.. now THAT is weird lol.



- armywifey26
on Jan. 3, 2013 at 12:49 PM