Question: So who was right?
Total Votes: 144
Let me set up the scenario for you and you tell me who was wrong.
We have a ton of family in right now. Yesterday there were 5 kids, 4 boys including my son and 1 girl. My son was outside talking to his favorite uncle who is in town from Florida, the other 4 kids were inside playing. One of the kids got ds's DSi game down from on top of the fireplace and left it laying in the floor along with about a million other games and toys. SIL came through and told them if they didn't pick their things up she would keep them. They didn't so when she came back through she picked up one game (ds's) and put it in her pocket. When ds went to look for it on the mantle the other kids told him she had it. (the other toys were still all over the floor) Ds asked SIL for it back and she told him he couldn't have it unless he made sure that everything stayed picked up all weekend. Ds and the uncle he was outside with thought that this was very unfair since he didn't even tell the other kids they could get it down and she didn't take anything away from the kids that were actually making the mess.