This my confession
I want to thank all you ladies for being kind and also those who offered different ways to get her off the binky.
Last Friday we had a goodbye binky party and threw them all away. The first two nights she asked for it at bedtime and I just told her they were gone. She whined a little, no tears though. I'm proud to say she has been binky free for 4 days and holding strong.
Again thank you all.