Join the Meeting Place for Moms!
Talk to other moms, share advice, and have fun!

(minimum 6 characters)

Chaplain Kathie: Glenn Beck’s mental health

Posted by on Apr. 3, 2014 at 12:57 AM
  • 4 Replies
1 mom liked this


By Chaplain Kathie STAFF WRITER

Glenn Beck was on the Today Show this morning with Keith Ablow M.D. talking out their book The 7 Wonders That Will Change Your Life.

Glenn Beck: How he recovered his life and his free will
The celebrated commentator shares the truth about his darkest moments

I am usually not interested in what Beck has to say but on this, I thought he was doing a great thing. Given the fact there are so many stories of the troops and veterans committing suicide, more turning to drugs (legal and illegal) along with alcohol abuse, this could have been a great moment in TV.

Beck has had to fight his own issues and went from the lowest of lows to having a huge platform with his radio show and FOX cable show. He also had to deal with the other part of his history.

Beck’s Mom committed suicide and he went through what most families left behind do to themselves. They beat themselves up with the “what if’s” as if they could have changed what happened when the truth is, everyone does the best they can with what they understood at the time.

My mother struggled with alcohol and drugs when I was a child. My parents eventually divorced and then, when I was thirteen, my mother killed herself. I had gone to visit her in the funeral home and had to wade through all the what-ifs. What if I had talked to her more that day? What if I had been there more for her that month? What if I had listened more to her that year? What if I had been a better son?

What did Beck do on the Today Show? Did he begin with talking about healing right away? Offering hope to the millions with mental illness? No it had to start with his political views.

When Beck talked about his relationship with Ablow, the co-author of the book, he said that he didn’t know what his political views were and that he was a nice guy. They had known each other since Beck’s CNN days. A nice guy? The point Beck missed is that there are a lot of nice people who do not live by the political point of view that everything is political. We do the best we can in our days and most of us have no idea what political view others have because it is not what matters most. The political war we see on cable is not the reality most of us live in.

Saying Ablow was a nice guy didn’t seem to sink into Beck’s brain that everything he says about the other side of politics is against other “nice people” he ends up hurting. It may get him ratings but does not do justice to the fact this book is supposed to be a self-help book and not a political one. The time taken up with political talk would have been fine had he addressed the fact that mental healthcare in most parts of the country is not available or covered on a lot of health insurance policies. The healthcare insurance reform bill Beck calls “Obamacare” covers mental healthcare for a lot of people who would not be treated otherwise. Could Beck address that fact and support it because he understands the devastating results of what can happen without the right care?

Beck’s book talks about freewill, which everyone has and they are responsible for their own actions most of the time but there is a broader picture when it comes to mental health. There are times when freewill has less to do with what happens and more to do with what doesn’t happen. Mental healthcare should never be something that is a dirty word but a vital one for the future of millions of families across this country. Those are the people Beck could have talked to this morning but that is just not his style.

The hope I had this morning came crashing down before the interview was over and I let the dog out. I just couldn’t watch it anymore. I wanted him to talk like everyone else, a human for a change, just trying to do the best he can as a person and not a political celebrity. He could have done a lot of good if he focused on the pain others have that he supposedly understands with his own past but he focused on himself instead. Beck should just stick with political books and not offer self-help books when he does a self-serving interview instead of a helpful one to others.

by on Apr. 3, 2014 at 12:57 AM
Add your quick reply below:
You must be a member to reply to this post.
Replies (1-4):
by Platinum Member on Apr. 3, 2014 at 5:16 PM
by Emerald Member on Apr. 3, 2014 at 7:44 PM
don't hate ! Beck is the bomb!
by Silver Member on Apr. 4, 2014 at 4:50 AM

Whiney as usual.

by Ruby Member on Apr. 4, 2014 at 6:48 AM

This is written by a chaplain? A person's whose job it is to listen to others?

Clearly, Chaplain Kathie couldn't get over Glenn Beck's politics. She could not see him as a person who needs help. So she judges him all over the place, because she disagrees with him politically. I am not impressed.

Chaplains and therapists are expected to deal with people as individuals and to disregard what is not important. And she can't do it. And this  is from 2011,  three years ago, for goodness sake. She needs to step down doing this. If she finds she can't fairly evaluate someone, she needs to stop and not print her article. Ouch.

This is very disappointing, and reflects on her. Not Glenn Beck. 

Add your quick reply below:
You must be a member to reply to this post.
Join the Meeting Place for Moms!
Talk to other moms, share advice, and have fun!

(minimum 6 characters)