Join the Meeting Place for Moms!
Talk to other moms, share advice, and have fun!

(minimum 6 characters)

Natural Birth & Parenting Natural Birth & Parenting

great article about essential oils from aromatherapist

Posted by on Sep. 25, 2013 at 10:45 AM
  • 22 Replies
3 moms liked this


Why I don’t use doTerra, Young Living or other Multi-Marketing Brands of Essential Oils

I get asked often why we don’t offer doTerra essential oils and so I wanted to compile in this blog post the reasons why including resources and references. However these are just some of many more references for essential oils. Please continue the conversation by researching aromatherapy further such as reading the books that I mention in this blog post and others.

Misunderstood marketing

doTerra uses the term “certified pure therapeutic grade” in their marketing. Well, it’s exactly only that – marketing. There aren’t any certified essential oils because there isn’t any recognized organization or agency that certifies essential oils. So, doTerra coined the term, put it on their bottles and trademarked (see the TM after the logo above) the term. What does it mean? Nothing as their oils are not certified. They use the term as their way of letting others know that they test their oils (like most essential oils good providers do). But, it makes for good marketing that doTerra sales reps (called “consultants”) and users most often than not misunderstand to mean that the oils are certified.

From doTerra’s website ~

CPTG Certified Pure Therapeutic Grade is a registered trademark of dōTERRA Holdings, LLC representing internal standards of quality assessment and material control. The CPTG protocol is not administered by government or industry regulatory agencies and does not imply regulatory approval of dōTERRA products.

An interesting and very informational article about this topic is the “The ‘Therapeutic Grade’ Essential Oils Disinformation Campaign.” by Cropwatch Organization. Click here to read the entire article.

Potential essential oil buyers should independently check out the marketing information provided by essential oil traders – do not be put off asking for any extra information or reassurances that you are legally entitled to if the situation is not absolutely clear cut. The professional aromatherapist has a duty to be able to provide all relevant safety information relevant to to their clients’ treatment(s) and therefore It is part of ‘due diligence’ to ask questions, require any stipulated proofs, request an MSDS, ask for compositional data & certificate of origin of the batch of oil purchased and have their eyes wide open to marketing ploys & scams of all types – including providing GC’MS print-outs and other information which relate to other batches of oils entirely, and, of course, describing essential oils as ‘therapeutic grade’.

Internal Use of Essential Oils

Consultants of doTerra are taught to recommend internal use of essential oils to the general public. However, this contradicts the respected advice and scope of practice recommended by Aromatherapy and Herbal associations, organizations and health care providers (including both mainstream and alternative medicines). Essential oils are quite potent. For example one drop of an essential oil is the equivalent of 75 cups of the herbal tea of the same plant. doTerra for example recommends for peppermint oil – “take one drop internally to calm indigestion or upset stomach” in their Introduction to Essential Oils. Essential oils are very powerful and there have been reported cases of poisonings and fatality due to the self-dosing of essential oils. It is not something to do lightly as I often see recommended by doTerra consultants.

The National Association of Holistic Aromatherapy (NAHA) warns -

Some oils are associated with toxicity problems (e.g. a risk of accumulative effects), and so internal use is not entirely hazard or risk-free.

The International Federation of Aromatherapists Code of Ethics states -

No aromatherapist shall use essential oils for internal ingestion or internal application nor shall any aromatherapist advocate or promote such use of essential oils unless the practicing aromatherapist has medical, naturopathic, herbalist, or similar qualifications and holds an insurance policy which specifically covers the internal application of essential oils. (IFA code of ethics. Simply Essential, No. 11 December 1993).

Salvatore Battaglia in The Complete Guide to Aromatherapy writes -

Oral administration does have a number of disadvantages:

  • possibility of nausea and vomiting
  • irritation of the gastrointestinal tract
  • much of the essential oil will be metabolized by the liver
  • destruction of the essential oil constituents by stomach acidity or enzymes in the intestines.

It’s common practice in the aromatherapy, herbalism, and alternative medicine health care that essential oils are not to be taken internally unless under the proper care of qualified care providers. There are two major aromatherapy organizations and both have in the scope of practice and ethics that members do not recommend the use of internal essential oils (to the general public for example), it’s in just about every aromatherapy respected book written by experts in the industry (some of which are quoted in this blog post). And it’s in all of the well known educational programs for aromatherapy and herbalism. They agree with each other on this. However, the only places it differs (not including personal blogs and such) is these multi-level marketing companies like doTerra and Young Living. They are actually the ones in the minority when it comes to recommending internal use of essential oils.

Undiluted (Neat) Use of Essential Oils

When I first was introduced to doTerra essential oils the consultant rubbed peppermint oil directly on my skin. Almost immediately I started to get a burning sensation and so she removed it with vegetable oil and rubbed wintergreen oil (also directed and undiluted) to my skin. In doTerra’s Introduction to Essential Oils almost every oil listed in the manual is recommended to use undiluted. Another brand, Young Living, recommends the use of undiluted essential oils as well. It’s interesting (as a side note) that doTerra emerged from a group of professionals that were a part of Young Living. But, when it comes to dilution – the use of undiluted essential oil is again also one not recommended by respected aromatherapy associations, experts and well-known educators in essential oils.

Because essential oils are so powerful, they should always be used diluted. The recommended correct dilution for topical use is 1% for children (avoid essential oils in newborns) and pregnant women, 2% for adults and 3% for medicinal use.  While there are some essential oils that are “skin friendly” such as lavender and tea tree oil (though skin patch test is recommended), they are the exception to the rule. Essential oils in general should be properly diluted before use.

Valerie Gennari Cooksley, R.N., Co-founder of Institute of Integrative Aromatherapy writes in her book Aromatherapy Soothing Remedies to Restore, Rejuvenate, and Heal -

Most essential oils you must dilute to use. Essential oils do not exist in nature in large quantities; they are tiny, microscopic droplets, unseen by the naked eye within the plant’s structure in miniscule quantity. So when you embark on your experiential study of nature’s gifts start by using highly diluted essential oils.

Allison England writes in Aromatherapy and Massage For Mother and Baby -

Essential oils are powerful and need to be diluted before applying directly to the skin. They should always be used either in a carrier oil, or mixed with water, some oils such as the citrus oils, could cause soreness and irritation.

I hope this helps to educate and clarify what is often seen and incorrectly provided by well-meaning sales reps of multi-level marketing brands of essential oils. While I’ve mentioned doTerra, this also does apply to Young Living. My intention is to educate and provide holistic wellness in a responsible way.  As I finish my Clinical Aromatherapy certification I find that within my scope of practice also comes the responsibility of providing correct recommendations and education when needed and absolutely when it comes to safety.

UPDATE: I’ve been asked quite often about specific brands and if it’s a good quality essential oil. I’d like to share with you how you can know yourself if a brand is a good quality brand by sharing a piece of an article from the East-West School of Herbal and Aromatics Study. I personally shop for essential oils in this way and encourage you to consider this as well. For example the brand of essential oils we carry at Granola Babies meets everything in this list. Don’t just pick a few things on this list and consider it a good essential oil ~ does it fit everything in this list? Does it fit at least the grand majority? This is how you go about choosing a quality essential oil brand.

  • who is dedicated to supplying essential oils to the aromatherapy practitioner market and educated public.
  • that is on the small size and not a large corporation.
  • owned by an aromatherapy practitioner or essential oil specialist
  • who has relations with his/her distillers, if possible
  • who can readily supply a batch-specific MS/GC spec report on each essential oil it sells
  • readily able to provide material safety data sheets (MSDS) as needed
  • who has a strong unquestioned noncontroversial reputation in the field
  • who has preferably been in the field for a number of years and is well known to other aromatherapy practitioners and/or educators

UPDATE 7/27/13 Comments or questions? Whether you agree or not with the sources and information provided, please keep your post polite. There have been some rude posts by Young Living and DoTerra sale reps so I’m  adding little note for future comments. As always, all posts have to be approved by admin before publishing so please only submit your post once.


source

by on Sep. 25, 2013 at 10:45 AM
Add your quick reply below:
You must be a member to reply to this post.
Replies (1-10):
ceckyl
by Bronze Member on Sep. 25, 2013 at 12:03 PM
Good info. Where do you get your oils?
MommaForever007
by on Sep. 25, 2013 at 12:09 PM
This

Quoting ceckyl:

Good info. Where do you get your oils?
funhappymom
by Bronze Member on Sep. 25, 2013 at 12:40 PM

I saw this on Facebook earlier. Interesting info.

Mrs.Salz
by on Sep. 25, 2013 at 3:53 PM
1 mom liked this

Mountain Rose Herbs. They distill their own and the quality is great IMO.


Quoting ceckyl:

Good info. Where do you get your oils?


jellyphish
by Platinum Member on Sep. 25, 2013 at 4:20 PM
Oh man. I was recently in a fb group where a poster asked for opinions on DT, so i gave mine which was essentially this. I inadvertently pissed off someone whom is probably a rep. She kept asking for sources, which I gave, but never sited her "info" beyond DT. Then the GO sent me a message reprimanding me for "starting marketing wars." WTF?! I swear, these companies go beyond salesmen, they are cults.

MRH, though, I love. I totally agree with you.
Posted on CafeMom Mobile
hapababies
by Silver Member on Sep. 25, 2013 at 4:52 PM
This article is so much what I have seen you say again and again.

I forget, why don't you prefer aura cacia?


Quoting jellyphish:

Oh man. I was recently in a fb group where a poster asked for opinions on DT, so i gave mine which was essentially this. I inadvertently pissed off someone whom is probably a rep. She kept asking for sources, which I gave, but never sited her "info" beyond DT. Then the GO sent me a message reprimanding me for "starting marketing wars." WTF?! I swear, these companies go beyond salesmen, they are cults.



MRH, though, I love. I totally agree with you.
Posted on CafeMom Mobile
jellyphish
by Platinum Member on Sep. 25, 2013 at 5:07 PM
The quality of AC is very poor. EOs are a buyer beware market, there are a lot of poor quality oils out there.

Quoting hapababies:

This article is so much what I have seen you say again and again.



I forget, why don't you prefer aura cacia?




Quoting jellyphish:

Oh man. I was recently in a fb group where a poster asked for opinions on DT, so i gave mine which was essentially this. I inadvertently pissed off someone whom is probably a rep. She kept asking for sources, which I gave, but never sited her "info" beyond DT. Then the GO sent me a message reprimanding me for "starting marketing wars." WTF?! I swear, these companies go beyond salesmen, they are cults.





MRH, though, I love. I totally agree with you.
Posted on CafeMom Mobile
hapababies
by Silver Member on Sep. 25, 2013 at 5:50 PM
It's a shame that it has a total monopoly over the mass market then. It's in the natural section of my grocery store, the main eo brand in the natural health store, and the only brand I have ever seen at whole foods. That makes me sad that the stores aren't looking into the quality of what they are selling.

Quoting jellyphish:

The quality of AC is very poor. EOs are a buyer beware market, there are a lot of poor quality oils out there.



Quoting hapababies:

This article is so much what I have seen you say again and again.





I forget, why don't you prefer aura cacia?






Quoting jellyphish:

Oh man. I was recently in a fb group where a poster asked for opinions on DT, so i gave mine which was essentially this. I inadvertently pissed off someone whom is probably a rep. She kept asking for sources, which I gave, but never sited her "info" beyond DT. Then the GO sent me a message reprimanding me for "starting marketing wars." WTF?! I swear, these companies go beyond salesmen, they are cults.







MRH, though, I love. I totally agree with you.
Posted on CafeMom Mobile
Precious333
by Gold Member on Sep. 25, 2013 at 6:01 PM
I cant wait to read the whole thing through. I juat skimmed. I did use eo on my newborn, it was diluted with coconut oil. I really want to build up my eo stash with pure oils, i was looking into youngliving and dterra.
jellyphish
by Platinum Member on Sep. 25, 2013 at 6:23 PM
It's just like anything else that's totally unregulated, you just have to research what you're getting. The health food stores don't know because they're not aromatherapists. And they want to appeal to the masses, and they do that with a low price point. It's just the way the market is.

Quoting hapababies:

It's a shame that it has a total monopoly over the mass market then. It's in the natural section of my grocery store, the main eo brand in the natural health store, and the only brand I have ever seen at whole foods. That makes me sad that the stores aren't looking into the quality of what they are selling.



Quoting jellyphish:

The quality of AC is very poor. EOs are a buyer beware market, there are a lot of poor quality oils out there.





Quoting hapababies:

This article is so much what I have seen you say again and again.







I forget, why don't you prefer aura cacia?








Quoting jellyphish:

Oh man. I was recently in a fb group where a poster asked for opinions on DT, so i gave mine which was essentially this. I inadvertently pissed off someone whom is probably a rep. She kept asking for sources, which I gave, but never sited her "info" beyond DT. Then the GO sent me a message reprimanding me for "starting marketing wars." WTF?! I swear, these companies go beyond salesmen, they are cults.









MRH, though, I love. I totally agree with you.
Posted on CafeMom Mobile
Add your quick reply below:
You must be a member to reply to this post.
Join the Meeting Place for Moms!
Talk to other moms, share advice, and have fun!

(minimum 6 characters)