Join the Meeting Place for Moms!
Talk to other moms, share advice, and have fun!

(minimum 6 characters)

How young is too young for pierced ears?

Posted by on Dec. 31, 2014 at 11:04 AM
  • 7 Replies

How to Tell if Kids Are Ready for Pierced Ears

Welcome to another milestone: your daughter (or maybe your son) has just announced, "I want to get my ears pierced." Don't bother asking them if they're sure they're ready. (Of course they're sure!) The question is do you think they are?

"Tweens and teens have to explore. That's their job. But they still need boundaries and both the too firm and too loose will fail them," says Marla Vannucci, PhD, associate professor at Adler School of Professional Psychology in Chicago and a licensed clinical psychologist in private practice.

Here, how to know if your kiddo's ready to get their ears pierced, and if so, how to get it done as painlessly (for both of you) as possible.

Do they have a good reason?

Don't focus so much on the age your child is, so much as their reason for wanting pierced ears.

"If your 5-year-old wants to look like her favorite princess, that may not be a good reason," says Vannucci. The same holds true if your teenage son's sole desire is to please a girlfriend. If they have a blowout fight next week, will he then regret having it done?

Ask your kid to tell you what's behind the decision, but "not in a 'convince me' kind of way," suggests Vannucci. Be empathetic and curious, and keep comments like "I know you won't like how it will look" to yourself. (Even if you're totally sure you're right.)

If what they tell you smacks of a passing fancy, then set a timeline, Vannucci says. "If they still want their ears pierced after a certain amount of time has passed, then you'll agree."

For most kids, though, you can relax. Ear piercing is "simply an age-appropriate way to begin to express oneself," says Vannucci.

But ... are they prepared for the pain?

So say your kid's reason for piercing seems legit to you. It's one thing to say you want your ears pierced. It's another to see a stranger looming over you with a piercing gun.

Want to know how -- or if -- your kiddo can cope? "Think about how she tolerates shots at the doctor," says Vannucci. "A fearless child might be ready sooner than one who tends to be more fearful, anxious, or less tolerant of pain."

Do your research and find a shop that has a reputation for being kid-friendly as well as clean. Then call ahead to find out exactly what the technician will do.

More From The Stir: Don't Pierce Your Daughter's Ears at the Mall

"You don't want to be surprised if you get there and they pull out a needle instead of a gun," says Vannucci. "Kids will do better when they know what to expect and what will happen in terms of the sensory experience." (For instance, you can try describing: "You'll feel a medium amount of pain, maybe like a flu shot, for about one second.")

Younger kids may do fine if they're distracted with, say, a video or game while it's happening. Interestingly, research shows kids over 12 usually don't feel distressed about ear piercing at all.

Will they really keep their pierced ears clean (and not just say they will)?

Of course, like everything, there are some health risks to consider. Some jewelry, especially nickel, can cause allergic reactions. Skin infections, which you'll recognize from any redness or pus, can arise. Let your kiddo know from the start how to care for her ear piercings and why it's so important. Then stand back and prepare to be impressed. Many kids immediately take ownership of this act "because it can bring about a sense of independence and pride," says Vannucci.

Seeing that, you might feel the same way.

How young is too young for pierced ears?

by on Dec. 31, 2014 at 11:04 AM
Add your quick reply below:
You must be a member to reply to this post.
Replies (1-7):
Missus_Mom
by New Member on Jan. 1, 2015 at 9:35 AM

We pierced our daughters ears  when she was six weeks old, so I am not the person to ask.  Our pedi did it, and she didnt' even flinch.

Anonymous
by Anonymous 1 on Jan. 1, 2015 at 9:37 AM
We pierced our daughter ears when she was a week old....she had her second holes done when she was 7
Maries_Mom23
by Member on Jan. 1, 2015 at 10:59 AM

When we found out that our first was a girl, we both decided her ears would be pierced when she asked.  Our thing was that they're not our ears, not our decision.  She asked 2 weeks shy of her 5th birthday.  She just got her second holes 6 weeks ago (she turned 11 in October).  We have another DD, who is 7 1/2 and has no interest in getting her ears pierced and that's fine.  She knows that if and when she wants them done, we'll take her to get them done.  

disneymom2two
by on Jan. 1, 2015 at 11:10 AM

We said we'd let them get them done whenever they asked plus a day.  My son asked to have his ear pierced at around 8 or 9.  The next day he'd changed his mind (the reason we make them wait a day).  He's 16 now and says he was glad we made him wait a day.  My daughter's 9 and swore up and down she was never going to get her ears pierced.  About a month ago, she changed her mind.  I told her we'd go that weekend to a local piercing parlor (due to extracurriculars, there was no earlier time to go).  She still wanted them that weekend so we went and did it.  She's thrilled with them.  

Anonymous
by Anonymous 2 on Jan. 1, 2015 at 4:47 PM
My daughter was four months old. I took her after her well baby check since my pedi's office hadn't started yet. There really is no scientific evidence that ear piercing is bad. I preferred to do it and take care of her ears. I cleaned then when I did diaper changes. She has never messed with her ears.

To each their own. I had mine pierced when I was a baby as well. I had a cousin who's father said she had to wait until she was 13.
DelilahsMom4108
by on Jan. 1, 2015 at 4:54 PM
We felt the same way I that they're not our ears, not our choice... my oldest daughter asked to get them done when she was 2...I told her she could do it: her 5th birthday but explained exactly what they would do and how it would feel...she got them done a few months after turning 6 because she wanted them done for kindergarten

Quoting Maries_Mom23:

When we found out that our first was a girl, we both decided her ears would be pierced when she asked.  Our thing was that they're not our ears, not our decision.  She asked 2 weeks shy of her 5th birthday.  She just got her second holes 6 weeks ago (she turned 11 in October).  We have another DD, who is 7 1/2 and has no interest in getting her ears pierced and that's fine.  She knows that if and when she wants them done, we'll take her to get them done.  

rpmracing
by New Member on Jan. 2, 2015 at 9:13 AM
Our first asked right before she turned 4...didn't cry or anything...she was very pleased....our other dd asked at 2...we explained it would hurt...but they are both really tough.. so we did. She didn't cry, but after the first she was hesitant but sat for the second...and that was it....I cleaned their ears.
Add your quick reply below:
You must be a member to reply to this post.
Join the Meeting Place for Moms!
Talk to other moms, share advice, and have fun!

(minimum 6 characters)