The CafeMom Newcomers Club
While reading another post about a mom losing her baby, I see so so many heartfelt & well intentioned replies. Some of them though, honestly are hurtful without meaning to be. So, I thought some of us who have "been there" can maybe help people understand what we would really rather not have heard, or continue to hear while dealing with such a loss. I don't expect to speak for everyone who's been through this, but I find that there's a lot of us who think similarly on this one....
So, here are a few that were painful for me to hear...
"It's God's will"
This is & always will be my number 1 thing not to say. Quite frankly many of us are a little peeved at God immediately following the loss. We either (1) don't care to talk about God at all, (2) don't believe in God in the same way you do, or (3) don't feel that our God would put us through such pain. We don't understand. We feel like we're being punished. We don't want to hear how God thinks this is best for us.
"At least you still have your other children"
Dosen't make this any less painful.
"At least you can still have another child." or "Are you going to try to have another child?"
It's not like ordering a repacement part for a car, or a new gravy boat as to not ruin a set of china. This was our child. A child we desperately wanted & loved. We don't want another child, we want this one....and we can't have them. The thought of trying again hasn't even occurred to us, & usually is a terrifying thought based on what we've just experienced.
"I know how you feel"
No. You don't. Even if you've been there, you don't. Every situation is different. Every person grieves differently. You have no idea how I feel, and I pray you never will.
"It's probably for the best"
I got this one a lot. My marriage was a wreck & my ex & I divorced several months after losing my daughter. People told me how much better off I was that I didn't have to go through all of that with 2 children. People are crazy. I would have done anything to have my child with me. Regardless of the situation it is never, ever, in our minds going to be "for the best."
I hope all of this doesn't come off too harsh. I know people mean well, but sometimes don't realize how what they're saying will be interpreted. Btw, I didn't read all of these things in the post I mentioned earlier, just a few, & I added others I've heard in "real life." Honestly, the best things to say are just "I'm sorry," "I'm thinking of you," and maybe, "is there anything I can do for you." And don't think we don't want to talk about it, don't think that we will ever forget. Most of us want to know our child is remembered, & thought of, & loved by people other than us. That their presence on this earth however brief touched people's hearts. So don't be afraid to say "I'm remembering you & your child today." For many that's a great comfort.
I hope some other moms will add some other tips that I may not have thought of. Hugs to all of you....
Edit....
I really hope everyone understands that I KNOW no one really knows what to say. I KNOW that you say what you think will comfort them. I KNOW the intentions are good. I'm not criticizing, I was only trying to offer advice because I, my best friend, & 2 of my sister in law's have all lost children in various stages of pregnancy & childhood. As a general rule these are the things that we found difficult to hear. It's not that we were offended, or hated the person saying them, simply that they were not helpful to us, and in some cases did cause us more pain.
|
|
by kfroz0415 on Jul. 2, 2008 at 1:44 PM
I've never lost a child and cannot imagine how painful it would be. I am sorry you had to go through that and I think many of us just don't know what to say.
![]() |
|
|
by singlemama20 on Jul. 2, 2008 at 1:45 PM
Those were the hardest things to hear with both of my losses. The best thing you can do for a mother losing her child is offer hugs and offer to be there if she needs to talk. There are no words sympathy doesn;t cut it. With me it was the knowledge I had someone I could talk to on my own time in my way. But otherwise there is really nothing you can do. So send a hug and if you have been there offer to help support someone who's going through it.
|
|
|
by mommy2twoangel on Jul. 2, 2008 at 1:46 PM
The reason people say these things is because they don't know what to say. They do not mean them in hurtful ways, they may have questions and are just trying to give comforting thoughts the way they know how or what is comforting to them. I have been there, I lost a child and if anyone said any of these things to me, I would not take offense or have been hurt, I would have seen the thought behind it and said thank you. I have been there, I hurt everyday and it has been 11 years.
|
|
|
by sukinova on Jul. 2, 2008 at 1:47 PM
I wish someone had passed that out to my friends and co-workers when I lost my DD. I would also add that not everyone wants a hug... especially from someone with whom no personal conversations have taken place...
You are right, everyone is different and responds differently to similar situations. I agree with everything you posted. Thanks |
|
|
by MommyLRW on Jul. 2, 2008 at 1:48 PM
Very well said. I have never been thru it and pray to God that I never have to! I'll do my best to be here for someone else, but I will NEVER try and act like I have any idea what the hell that person is going thru!
|
|
|
by Aislinn on Jul. 2, 2008 at 1:50 PM
Good info, Mama.
|
|
|
by AndreaB. on Jul. 2, 2008 at 1:50 PM
I agree with your post. They just had an article in Parents or Parenting about things to say and not say when other people are in tough situations like losing a child.
I miscarried when I was 21 and in college. Someone said, "Well at least it won't ruin your life now. You can get your degree get a job and provide a more stable life for your next child." OUCH!!! I know it was meant to be kind, but it still stung. -Collin and Madelyn's Mom |
|
|
by stacey0716 on Jul. 2, 2008 at 1:51 PM
I think alot of those can be applied to anyone who has lost someone, I know when my DF died, I would get questions like that. Like the "are you going to remarry" and stuff like that. I hated it when people would tell me it was God's will, and then turn around and tell me to pray to him for strength. At Nick's funeral, I would not even pray, I wanted nothing to do with him at that moment. I think the stupidest thing anyone has ever said to me was when HIS mother said, "it could be worse, he could have left you for another woman" WTF how would that be worse? At least my children would have their father, but I guess I'm not a selfish bitch so I didn't get where she was coming from.
But one thing I did learn with his death is that no matter what you say to someone who has just suffered loss, it's honestly not going to change anything, so I never know what to say when someone I know is going through that because I know, no matter what, it won't heal them so I just say, "I'm sorry" that's all I can say! BTW I remember talking with you about your story, and you are a strong woman!!
|
|
|
by steph1012 on Jul. 2, 2008 at 1:52 PM
My brother lost his little boy when he was 2 years old. It wasn't his fault, but to this day (7 years later) still feels that it is. (He died in a fire and my brother was unable to get to him in time)
He told us that the best thing that anyone done for him was me and my other brother going to him and just sitting beside him not saying a word. He said that he just felt better knowing we were there for him and not trying to "cheer him up". ♥Stephanie♥
|
|
|
by Airmans_Wifey on Jul. 2, 2008 at 1:52 PM
after my miscarriage I hated hearing
"well it was never a baby anyways because it wasnt viable" "you wern't that far along better for it to happen now than after you felt the baby move" " you need to move on, at least you can have other kids" i heard so many of these i dont understand how people can be so heartless. however i didnt mind hearing from other people that tehy knew how i felt if they had already been through it, it helped to talk to someone who accually knew what i was going through |
Only group members can reply to this post.