for the mamas who have got their dd's an American girl doll how old are they/were they and what do you think of them.i got the new nov catalogue in the mail and i think they are soo cute i love the babies but my 22 is only 2 and they are expensive but i had my dd looking at with me and everything was 'omg mommy its soo cute" so im not sure so you input would really help
I definately would not get them for a 2 year old. Target has these dolls called Generation girls or something that look almost exactly like the American Girl dolls and they are only like $25. I'd get her that instead.
I got my first American girl doll when I was about 8 and boy did I love her. I still have her. She was my favorite. We got my SIL one when she was about 12. I would say about 5-6 is the earliest just because they are so expensive. She would love one now but I would find it hard to get her one. There are other options out there for her. maybe a cabbage patch kid?
~ Erin ~
Married to Christopher ~ 27 August 2005
Mother to Liam Christopher ~ 28 April 2009
Do not go where the path may lead, go instead where there is no path and leave a trail. ~ Ralph Waldo Emerson
no im not getting for her now i was thinkinh for her b-day they have american girl dolls for 3yr olds
Quoting two4one:
I definately would not get them for a 2 year old. Target has these dolls called Generation girls or something that look almost exactly like the American Girl dolls and they are only like $25. I'd get her that instead.
Get her the bitty baby one. It will last, and if it does get some damage, you can send it out to be repaired for a small fee. Plus they are what $40, not bad.
I would hold off on the traditional AG dolls till she's 5/6 though OR proves she can be responsible with it. I still have my Samantha doll from when I was little, and my DD will get it eventually (along with her own). Of course, buying them is also partially self-indulging lol.
Join us on

The New Jersey Moms Group!
NJ Moms Group Mod
thats what im thinking because she is in love with it and then i was thinkinh next yr when she turns 4 getting her the AG doll if she is ready
Quoting mrsJLA:
Get her the bitty baby one. It will last, and if it does get some damage, you can send it out to be repaired for a small fee. Plus they are what $40, not bad.
I would hold off on the traditional AG dolls till she's 5/6 though OR proves she can be responsible with it. I still have my Samantha doll from when I was little, and my DD will get it eventually (along with her own). Of course, buying them is also partially self-indulging lol.










- Beautiful__mama
on Nov. 21, 2009 at 3:44 PM