Join the Meeting Place for Moms!
Talk to other moms, share advice, and have fun!

(minimum 6 characters)

How to Have a Drama Free Holiday

Posted by on Nov. 11, 2016 at 11:38 AM
  • 5 Replies

Expert Tips for a Drama-Free Holiday -- Even If Your Family Is Politically Divided

Mackenzie Dawson

Thanksgiving familyYou might be feeling devastated by the results of the election -- or you might be pleased as punch. But either way, it's safe to say that by the time the Thanksgiving holiday rolls around, emotions will still be running high: anger, fear, disbelief, happiness, excitement, all depending on whom you cast your ballot for. But whether you wanted to be #WithHer or to #MakeAmericaGreatAgain, chances are you could be sitting next to that friend or family member on Thanksgiving who feels very, very differently. And you might not know how to deal with it. 

In the interests of celebrating this holiday and being able to have conversations that don't end in slammed doors and tossed sweet potato casseroles, we chatted with Alexandra Carter, the director of the Edson Queiroz Foundation Mediation Program and a clinical professor of law at Columbia Law School. Carter has trained everyone from UN delegates to judges on the art of mediation, so if there's one person bound to be able to teach you the art of diplomacy at the family table, it's probably her.

"The work that I do is designed to help people no matter what the difficult topic at hand," says Carter. "These skills work with diplomats, law firms, Fortune-100 CEOS, 8-year-old girls -- and they will work on your Uncle Carl." Here are five tips she suggests for a peaceful holiday:

1. Each family must decide: Politics? Or no politics?
This won't be the same for each family, so you'll have to decide what works best for yours. "We've made a no-politics rule at our Thanksgiving this year," says Carter. "We've decided that for my family, the thing that works best is to focus on the things we love, like eating and college football. But other families will need to talk about it, and that's fine, too." 

2. Practice active listening.
"Listening does not mean just shutting up and giving the person your attention. Often when people [who disagree politically] are in these conversations, people stop listening to each other; we prefer to listen in a bubble," says Carter. "I teach active listening, without interruption. After you've done that, you can start to ask questions. 'Tell me more when you say you feel left behind.' 'When you say you can't trust Hillary, what concerns you most?' The number one way to take the steam off the kettle is to listen actively. And do it before the other person does it to you. If they perceive that you are genuinely open, they may reach a place where they are willing to try to understand you more." 

3. Remember that each conversation really contains three levels.
And try to have empathy for the emotion behind someone's political mindset. "The first level is what's happening -- the facts of how one person feels. For instance, Uncle Carl thinks immigrants are taking his job. Now let's get to level two, the feelings beneath what makes Uncle Carl feel left behind," explains Carter. "Finally, the deepest level is the identity conversation, where you ask yourself, 'What does this mean about who I am and why we're having this conversation. Am I as tolerant as I think I am?'" 

4. Ask, don't attack. 
"The first thing is, for the person experiencing the disconnect, to take it back and realize that different people react to stuff differently. Rather than say, 'How could you?', ask questions. Not cross-examination questions. Be genuinely curious. And if you're feeling angry, pretend that your friend or family member is a character in a story you're trying to understand. Show them that you are making an attempt to understand, and from there, you can get into your different reaction. The friend will be in more of a place to hear it, having been deeply understood."

5. Frame the situation.  
That is, try to find the similarity when the difference feels like an insurmountable gulf. "Say something like, 'You and I have the best interests of the country at heart,'" suggests Carter. "'We both care deeply about issues that are very passionate to us. We have a few things we can disagree with, but more that we can agree on.' Sometimes people think there is a chasm because of one big issue, but we may hold very similar beliefs. We can still love each other."

by on Nov. 11, 2016 at 11:38 AM
Add your quick reply below:
You must be a member to reply to this post.
Replies (1-5):
by Becky on Nov. 11, 2016 at 2:05 PM

I jokingly told my sister I can't spend Thanksgiving with her and her family, because they all voted differently than I.  She knows I was kidding!!!

by on Nov. 11, 2016 at 6:35 PM

LOL I so can't see none of that working with my dysfunctional in laws

by Louann on Nov. 11, 2016 at 7:18 PM

Thankfully we never have a problem getting together.  We all get along even if we have different opinions etc...

by Gold Member on Nov. 11, 2016 at 9:27 PM

True Story: Nine years ago, while my 21 year old Marine son was in his first deployment in Iraq, I celebrated Christmas Day at my brother's lovely home with his wife, his daughter, and our widowed mom.  My husband had to work, so I picked up Mom and drove us to my brother's.  It was the worst Christmas ever and I was very sad and depressed - my only child was in combat 6000 miles away, my husband had to work, and my opinionated SIL was drinking. Unfortunately, the news was on TV and when an item about the war came on, my SIL called it "a stupid little war".  Well, I lost it!  25 years of pent up hostility toward her bubbled over in that instant I let her have it with both barrels - I told her everything I'd wanted to tell her but politely held it in for the sake of my brother and my parents, how opinionated, jealous, belittling she was. (I found out after my brother's death 6 years ago he was planning to divorce her).  I stormed out of the house and went home.  It turned out to be my Mom's last Christmas - she became ill about 6 weeks later and died 4 months later, happily, it was a month after my son got home from his deployment and they were reunited. No family gathering ever got that intense for any reason, politics or otherwise, but my brother's wife had been needling me for years.  I forgave her ( but never forgot it) and we are still in touch, though she never brought that incident up afterwards.  I guess the only moral here is: you can certainly use all of the above suggestions, but there will always be that one relative who is an ass.  Thanks for "listening".

american flag ribbon

by Lisa on Nov. 12, 2016 at 9:30 AM

We are all lound and slightly insane in our family. There is rarely drama but there is always tons of noise!

Add your quick reply below:
You must be a member to reply to this post.
Join the Meeting Place for Moms!
Talk to other moms, share advice, and have fun!

(minimum 6 characters)