I'm thinking a 2008ish VW Jetta
A 2008ish Toyota Corolla or maybe a 2009ish Honda Fit. I'm open to some other suggestions too. My requirements are: 4 doors, reliable, MPG and has to not look like an old lady car! I LOVE the new 2012 Acura ILX but I don't have that kind of cash lying around and I DO NOT want a payment!