Will Black Voters Punish Obama for His Support of Gay Rights?
They say the arc of history bends toward justice. If that‚Äôs true then as a nation we‚Äôre having a hard time bending on the issue of gay rights. But this week will be remembered as an historic turning point because President Obama threw political caution to the wind and came out as the man who can put principle over politics in announcing his support for marriage equality. ‚ÄúI‚Äôve just concluded that for me personally it is important for me to go ahead and affirm that I think same sex couples should be able to get married,‚ÄĚ Obama told Robin Roberts in an interview to appear on ABC‚Äôs ‚ÄúGood Morning America‚ÄĚ Thursday.
Polls show America is trending toward embracing gay marriage. We now have a thin and growing majority that supports marriage equality. And we have the young Millennial generation strongly in favor of marriage equality while the older Boomers are firmly against. But national acceptance of gay marriage remains a long, hard slog. This week, North Carolina planted its feet in the past by becoming the 30th state to legally prohibit gay marriage and also abolished civil unions, thus enshrining romantic segregation in their state constitution. Separate and unequal in matters of the heart. We should all be ashamed that we‚Äôre still restricting civil rights to certain groups of Americans. Barring gays from marriage says their committed relationships don‚Äôt merit the protection or sanctity of marriage‚ÄĒan important step both socially and legally. It says their love and commitment is of lesser value. The sanctity of marriage in America has not been compromised by the thousands of married gay couples we already have. The institution of marriage was mocked by the sham made-for-TV 72 day marriage of Kim Kardashian and yet no bill has been proposed barring her from the altar.
In North Carolina we can see why the President‚Äôs position on marriage equality is so politically risky. Despite Presidents Obama and Clinton calling for the Amendment‚Äôs defeat, North Carolinians voted enthusiastically in favor of Amendment One with the highest turnout for a primary in 25 years. 500,000 people voted early, another primary record. Gay marriage is an issue that draws people to the polls in droves‚ÄĒeven in a state where there was already a law banning same sex marriage. It is an issue that people on both sides of the debate feel deeply and intensely and one that could shape the election. For the President to support marriage equality will perhaps bring in big money from gay donors, will embolden some supporters who were disappointed by his equivocation about gay rights and who will be inspired by him standing up for what he believes. Trying to protect a legally oppressed group of Americans is what the bully pulpit is for. But this step could endanger him in the South and in heavily religious states and with black Americans. Supporting marriage equality could damage his chance for re-election as much as any other issue. It‚Äôs one that strikes deep into how people feel about the core values of their nation and their Bible.
The constituency calculus makes this choice politically risky for Obama. Black voters, who were critical to Obama‚Äôs ‚Äė08 victory, are strongly against marriage equality. A recent Washington Post/ABC poll found 55% of blacks oppose gay marriage and 42% support it, which is almost the opposite of white voters‚ÄĒ53% support and 43% oppose. This opposition, I think, comes from what many blacks are told by their church. Black antipathy toward gay rights is so deep that the National Organization for Marriage was planning to use it as part of their strategy in their battle to prevent marriage equality. A secret memo revealed their ‚ÄúNot A Civil Right Project‚ÄĚ whose goal was ‚Äúto drive a wedge between gays and blacks.‚ÄĚ They would do this by finding and publicizing blacks who‚Äôd object to gay marriage as a civil right thus provoking gay marriage supporters into ‚Äúdenouncing [them] as bigots.‚ÄĚ The point was divide and conquer: ‚ÄúNo politician wants to take up and push an issue that splits the base of the party.‚ÄĚ And just like that blacks would become pawns of social conservatives, helping to block gays from a civil right.
I suspect it might have worked because I usually find that linking the gay rights struggle with the battle for racial justice in any way tends to elicit angry responses from many black people. Many show no empathy for gays as another legally oppressed minority and have no desire to see any similarity between the two historically oppressed identity groups. I hear people talk about how much harder and more violent life has been for black Americans than gay Americans as if there‚Äôs an Oppression Olympics. The comparison is irrelevant. Hearing of the legalized discrimination of a group of people should send chills down black backs. We know what that feels like.
With blacks lagging behind the country on marriage equality but still a crucial bloc for Obama, the White House has made a courageous bet that black voters won‚Äôt punish him and that being on the right side of history will not eventually hurt him. Obama has seemed to want to overtly support marriage equality for a while‚ÄĒa year ago he said gays, ‚Äúare our brothers, our sisters, our children, our cousins, our friends, our coworkers, and they‚Äôve got to be treated like every other American‚Ä¶ I think we‚Äôre moving in a direction of greater equality and ‚ÄĒ and I think that‚Äôs a good thing.‚ÄĚ Meanwhile his administration has repealed don‚Äôt ask, don‚Äôt tell, refused to back the Defense of Marriage Act, and expanded federal hate crime law to protect gays. Hillary Clinton, in Geneva in December, said, ‚ÄúGay rights are human rights and human rights are gay rights.‚ÄĚ And this week Vice President Biden said he was, ‚Äúabsolutely comfortable with the fact that men marrying men, women marrying women and heterosexual men and women marrying one another are entitled to the same exact rights.‚ÄĚ But, until now the President remained cautious about publicly favoring gay marriage. Does this mean North Carolina and other states that are staunchly anti-gay marriage are lost? Does it mean Obama would rather stand on principle and lose than be a politician and win? Or perhaps he sees this as part of a victory strategy that rebrands himself as the courageous politician who will take hard stands and will stand up for the people.