Chicken and waffles: so delicious, yet so controversial.
Call fried chicken and waffles a traditional Southern food, and you're liable to get accused of a damn Yankee conspiracy.
That's what we found out last week, when our story
about the dangers of a Southern fried diet prompted many of you with
roots in the South to protest – don't pin that dish on us! Here's a
sampling of the comments we received:
"I'm a southerner, and I have never heard of fried chicken on a waffle!"
"I live in the deep, deep, deep South and I've never seen them in any of the 'soul' food places I eat."
grew up in the South. The first time I heard of fried chicken and
waffles was during a summer working in LA ... definitely an LA thing and
not southern thing."
"This is a Yankee-fied interpretation of a southern staple."
visceral reaction got us wondering: Were we wrong to assign this blend
of carbs and fried goodness a Southern backstory? We put the question to
John T. Edge, the director of the Southern Foodways Alliance and author of Fried Chicken: An American Story.
"It's a Southern dish," Edge tells The Salt, "but a Southern dish once or twice removed from the South."
a dish most popular among expatriate, African-American Southerners," he
adds, "a dish most popular among Southerners now living in urban areas,
whether that be the urban South or the urban West, in the case of Los
Angeles, or the urban North, in the case of New York."
So is it
breakfast or dinner? Edge says there are no rules – except that the
chicken should be on the bone. He prefers the dish with dark meat, a
drizzle of maple syrup and a hit of Tabasco.
As Edge recounts in his book, both
the East and West coasts get credit for popularizing fried chicken and
waffles. In the 1930s, the combo was a signature offering at Well's Supper Club
– a Harlem haunt that was a favorite of Sammy Davis Jr. and Nat King
Cole. Out in Los Angeles, Roscoe's chain of soul food restaurants
brought chicken and waffles to the Hollywood crowd starting in the
But Edge suspects the dynamic duo has probably been a
part of America's culinary repertoire for much longer — since the
nation's earliest days, when Thomas Jefferson brought a waffle iron back
from France. As for where chicken and waffles originated? Edge thinks
it was multiple places — including the South.
chicken, wringing its neck and cooking it for breakfast is a pretty
traditional thing to do" in rural areas, he says. That's true in the
South, he says, but also in the Midwest and in Pennsylvania Dutch
country – where people have been pairing waffles with chicken — creamed,
not fried – for centuries.
Adding a waffle may seem exotic, he
says, but it's really not far removed from chicken and biscuits or
chicken and corn bread – a waffle being a form of "quick bread." In many
rural parts, he says, it was fairly common for a farm woman to kill a
chicken on Sunday morning, batter it up, cook it in a cast-iron skillet
and serve it for breakfast with some form of quick bread.
"That's a traditional dish," Edge says.
Hmm ... traditional. So why did we raise the hackles of so many readers? Edge has a theory.
time you talk about fried chicken in the South," says Edge, "you're in
essence talking about somebody's mama, and when you talk about
somebody's mama, somebody gets mad."