I don't know...maybe a combination of both. Our two daughters are ten years apart in age. They are complete opposites. There is very little about the two that is similar....except maybe their looks, and their love of I Love Lucy :-)
A little of both.
It's definitely more nature. My ds acts like his grandfather; my dd acts like her great grand-mother and the youngest is all daddy's boy!!!!!! ( they just have my good looks LOL)
IMO more nature than nurture, but the environment is still really important.
My two oldest have kind of a similar personality, but my twins are very much different. One loves being around people and the other could care less about being around people, this two year old boy allows no one to pick him up.
I think it's a mix of both. I think nature is the main factor, but nurture can cause lots of change.
Nature is the base. You can use nurture to channel it, but my three kids have all been raised basically the same way and are still very different.
I think a couple of things about this:
~ Even triplets are not living the same experience in one house growing up: their different personalities mean they pay attention to different things, and those things will mean various things to each of them ... what one thinks was really important another might not even have noticed
~ personality types (like the MBPTI) are really durable and can be tested from early childhood to late adulthood with identical results
~ character may or may not develop, may develop for a while and then stop, or may not start to develop until late in life --which has nothing to do with nurture or nature
~ what happens to us is important to who we become, but it's the us it's happening to that causes meaning: this is why identical circumstances mean such varied things to different people
Connect with CafeMom:
Switch to Mobile Site
Getting Started Guide
Frequently Asked Questions
Part of the CafeMom family of sites
© 2013 CMI Marketing, Inc. All rights reserved.