Join the Meeting Place for Moms!
Talk to other moms, share advice, and have fun!

(minimum 6 characters)

Fear Trumps logic every time

Posted by on Aug. 28, 2009 at 10:21 AM
  • 5 Replies

Past efforts to overhaul the nation's health care system had different proponents, different opponents and different plans that were under consideration. But they have two things in common: They all ended in failure, and in every case, opponents used fear as a key weapon in their arsenal.

So Jonathan Oberlander, a political scientist at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, says he's not at all surprised to see recent claims — all thoroughly debunked — that suggest, for example, that bills under consideration would encourage senior citizens to commit suicide when they become ill or infirm.

"It's really a case of deja vu," he says. "You hear in today's debate echoes of the past that extend all the way to the early part of the 20th century. And I think the reason that people use fear again and again is that it's effective. It's worked to stop health reform in the past. And so they're going to try and use it in the present."

History Of Scare Tactics

Oberlander says opponents used scare tactics the very first time the idea of national health insurance was broached — around 1915 — by tying would-be reformers to the nation's then-greatest international threat.

"They said that national health insurance was a plot by the German emperor to take over the United States," he says.

The next effort to remake the health system came during the late 1940s. This time the opposition, led by the American Medical Association, exploited the newest fears. "They said if we adopted national health insurance, the Red army would be marching through the streets of the U.S.; they said this was the first step toward communism," Oberlander says.

By the time the Clinton administration took on the health effort, the power of the American Medical Association was fading. But now a new opponent took its place — the health insurance industry. It ran ads using an ordinary looking couple, named Harry and Louise, to raise doubts among middle-class Americans about how the Clinton plan might hurt rather than help them.

Says Oberlander, "The opponents have changed over time; the tactic of relying on fear and scaring Americans has not."

The Science Of Fear

But exactly why is fear such an effective tactic? Simple biology, says Joseph LeDoux, a professor of neuroscience at New York University.

It turns out that fear is a very primitive response, and "once fear is aroused in your brain, it tends to take over and dominate," LeDoux says. A brain paralyzed by fear is unable to think other things through.

It actually makes sense on a survival level, he says. "If there's a chance that you'll be harmed, then you better attend to it. In other words, you better be afraid of it and be careful about what's going on."

There's another thing that makes fear effective in political debates — it's contagious.

"Rats have ways of sending out ultrasonic calls to other rats to warn them that, say, a cat is nearby," LeDoux says. "And these sounds are a secret code, because they're outside the cat's hearing ability. So it's pretty primitive in nature that we have these kinds of mechanisms for detecting danger, for experiencing danger within the individual, and for sharing that information across individuals."

Biology Wins

Republicans insist that fear is not part of their strategy in trying to defeat the current health overhaul effort. "No one's trying to scare people with sound bites. I mean, you know, I've not done that, and I don't know any of the leaders in the House and Senate that have done that," Republican National Committee Chairman Michael Steele said on NPR earlier this week.

But that's not convincing to many political scientists like Oberlander, who say they're hearing a lot of what they consider to be deliberate scare tactics.

"Fear is crowding out the truth. And the truth ought to count for something in health care reform and American politics. And right now it doesn't," he says.

The current debate isn't yet over, but so far at least, biology has defeated logic every time.

 

http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=112315433&sc=fb&cc=fp

by on Aug. 28, 2009 at 10:21 AM
Add your quick reply below:
You must be a member to reply to this post.
Replies (1-5):
lilyrose73
by on Aug. 28, 2009 at 10:59 AM

People are NOT scared of health reform... people are PISSED OFF that once again our Government is trying to pass a bill that will do nothing but increase our debt by TRILLIONS of dollars and won't help the people that need health care the most.  This isn't about opposing health care reform in general, it's about this particular bill and the arrogance of congress in trying to shove this pile of shit down our throats... 

 


 


Champions find a way... Losers find an excuse

ilovemymonkeys4
by on Aug. 28, 2009 at 12:19 PM

good

Quoting lilyrose73:

People are NOT scared of health reform... people are PISSED OFF that once again our Government is trying to pass a bill that will do nothing but increase our debt by TRILLIONS of dollars and won't help the people that need health care the most.  This isn't about opposing health care reform in general, it's about this particular bill and the arrogance of congress in trying to shove this pile of shit down our throats... 


margroc
by on Aug. 28, 2009 at 12:27 PM

When Canada reformed their healthcare back in the 50s there were all sorts of shouts of "commie", "people will die", "doctors will be poor", the doctors in Saskatchewan went on strike, it was a big hairy mess.  Kind of what I'm watching now go on the States.  Our country didn't die, we are a still extremely free and have one of the highest qualities of living in the world.  Change is scary but sometimes it's for the best.

Living next to you is in some ways like sleeping with an elephant. No matter how friendly and even-tempered is the beast, if I can call it that, one is affected by every twitch and grunt. - Pierre E. Trudeau

Raintree
by Ruby Member on Aug. 28, 2009 at 12:27 PM

Not necessarily. There are some that are scared. And I think it could be argued that a specific tactic is being used to promote a variety of negative emotions toward ANY health reform. 

Quoting ilovemymonkeys4:

good

Quoting lilyrose73:

People are NOT scared of health reform... people are PISSED OFF that once again our Government is trying to pass a bill that will do nothing but increase our debt by TRILLIONS of dollars and won't help the people that need health care the most.  This isn't about opposing health care reform in general, it's about this particular bill and the arrogance of congress in trying to shove this pile of shit down our throats... 



The liberal person shall be enriched, and he who waters shall himself be watered. Proverbs 11:25

sweetie00
by on Aug. 28, 2009 at 12:34 PM


Quoting lilyrose73:

People are NOT scared of health reform... people are PISSED OFF that once again our Government is trying to pass a bill that will do nothing but increase our debt by TRILLIONS of dollars and won't help the people that need health care the most.  This isn't about opposing health care reform in general, it's about this particular bill and the arrogance of congress in trying to shove this pile of shit down our throats... 

Lilyrose, are you opposed to single payer? UHC? And do you agree that most of the opposition is just PHRMA, Ins.- scare tactics? Trying to keep us under their thumbs?

Add your quick reply below:
You must be a member to reply to this post.
Join the Meeting Place for Moms!
Talk to other moms, share advice, and have fun!

(minimum 6 characters)