Tags: article, america, liberty, freedom
Everyone can see this journal post.
Your post reminds me of the Stalin story .. pluck the feathers from a sparrow, one by one, and soon he is thankful for the warmth of your hand.
Very well stated. As a person who grew up on welfare from time to time, it saddens me to see it abused. My father was a proud man, but unfortunately was in a seasonal type of job that did not pull in much money. So we used medicaide and food stamps periodically when I was growing up. But we never relied on them for long periods of time. I received much judgement as a teen because in a small town like mine - everyone knows who is on welfare and who is not. I always got comments that we were lazy and abusing the system.
So, when you said the following, I was glad that you recognize that some form of help is needed from time to time: "Hard times come for many but living a lifestyle completely from the welfare system is a blow to the heart of the society that was created for us to thrive in."
So what do I feel I'm entitled to? I say I'm entitled to the freedom to seek information and make my own decisions. I feel that so much information is hidden to us becaue it may somehow harm the super-large corporations who flip their $$$ in the face of our government. And when people do uncover the truth, their labled as weird or trouble makers.
Well spoken! I couldn't agree more!
Another problem is that the average American does not understand that taking money away from one person to give to another is just plain... stealing! Who is to say who needs that money more? Should the hardworking father of a family of 6 have to pay for another person's unemployment, simply because he has worked hard for decades to attain a higher level of income than that other person, or simply because one person "appears" to need that money more?
We cannot change this system until more people are educated as to the unedeniable HARM that comes from the entitlement mentality.
It's an excellent perspective presented very well. I wonder though, might it be that we actually are entitled to a certain standard of living in a society as advanced as ours is in so many ways? Might it be that in looking at welfare recipients of today as less worthy than their predecessors or working peers a divisive attitude is fostered that in the end serves only the interests of those who are and wish to remain in power? What if, instead of saying, "I need, it's my money" we say, "We all deserve, it's our economy" and demand that our government and others of the world who wish to participate interdependently (not to be confused with co-dependence) provide all of their people with basic necessities including clean water, food, housing, clothing, education, and healthcare. I understand this sounds like a socialist perspective, but in truth, those things if they are given unconditionally through a pooling of a small amount of each individual's resources, serve to foster freedom in thought and expression, which are the truest of libertarian principles. I don't have an issue with government, and I don't have an issue with supporting others in my community, as long as the government works for me and my fellow citizens rather than for itself, and as long as those others... well, how much laying-about I'd be willing to accept (in my ideal world) would depend upon how much society could afford. I don't care if everyone's doing nothing all day if that's what they wish, if we as a people can afford it and no one's being left with some unreasonable burden.
I offer this not as an argument, but as an alternative. I think it's true that we feel entitled in many ways that serve us in no way, as individuals or a social group. I just wonder if maybe our frustration with the situation isn't misdirected when I find that, for instance, all the people I know personally who are using or have used social services have good reason, so when I find myself getting up in arms about it I end up wondering why for every layabout someone knows there seem to be two or three or four families with true hardship and need.
Or, do we need to redefine hardship and need? Or all of that? I don't know. :)
Peace - You make some valid points, issues I've been thinking about lately myself after having spent time in a country that was developed by the British, but is now like a 3rd world country where people are SO poor, they literally do not have enough food sometimes, they don't always have running water (and I'm talking about in a major city ), they dont' always have electricity etc. It makes us wonder just how much weas Americans are entitled to - but at the same time, wondering if maybe the govt SHOULD be involved in providing some of those things. Hmmm....
Peacejaway - after I responded to you I had a chance to finally read Mary Ruwart's book Healing our World in an Age of Aggression.
I highly recommend it! avail free online at http://www.ruwart.com
She goes thru a step-by-step explanation of how (the aggression of) taxing people to give to others actually hurts the poor & disadvantaged the most... while at the same time, giving people freedom from such aggression & the liberty to make their own choices actually helps the poor & disadvantaged the most!
An eye-opening book! It really helped resolve my concerns about how to provide for those less fortunate and raising the standard of living for Americans (all people, actually).
Click here to register for CafeMom
Already a member?Click here to log in
and people wonder why am not patriotic. so many times i have heard, "if you don't like it then leave". why? why not fix it? why not voice my opinion?
i have heard, "at least you aren't starving" or, "at least you aren't being bombed". ok, sure. so should the women that fought so hard for the right to vote have just shut up and been glad they didn't have to wear burkas? should african americans have even bothered to fight for their freedom? at least they didn't have to face genocide right?
i just don't understand the complacency. yes, we have it better than others, because we fought for it.
goth_mama Jun. 13, 2008 at 7:49 AM