Tyler has a band class she is playing the sax she doesn't like it she says it's too hard...

  • September 5, 2008 at 12:27 AM by karenlyne
  • 2 Comment(s)
  • 17 Total Views

She wants me to give the teacher permission to change instraments. but since she had only been playing it for less than a week I think she hasn't given it enough time to know if she likes it, I told her to give it two more weeks then decide

Am I wrong for this??

Comments:

Ewans...

As a musician and music educator I think the best scenario would be to take her in after school one day (soon) and let her try a couple different instruments.  Hopefully her teacher will agree with this.  That way she'll get a feel for what she might like to play instead of the sax.  Woodwind instruments can be very challenging for kids who have midline balance (a very strong right hand but weak left hand or vice versa).  I myself am a brass girl for just this reason...and because my mom started me on trumpet when I was five. lol

Give her a shot on trumpet and see how she does.  Most of all, talk to her teacher and get her set on "her" instrument soon.  The longer you wait, the more she'll have to catch up when she does switch.

Good luck!

EwansMommy Sep. 5, 2008 at 12:55 AM

my4pi...

Wow sorry to hear your daughter doesnt like the sax,, my daughter will be learning to play the sax this year also..I do hope she likes it though....     I would give her time and maybe try a new instrument... But try to make sure thats its the sax she doesnt like or if theres something else bothering her.

my4pinkroses Sep. 5, 2008 at 6:12 AM

Want to leave a comment and join the discussion?

Click here to register for CafeMom

Already a member?Click here to log in

© 2008 CMI Marketing, Inc. All rights reserved.