I enjoy reading posts over at the Science Blogs.  This post today really addresses well the problem with "a little bit of knowledge can be a dangerous thing" or "The Arrogance of Ignorance".  For the full post, just click on the title.

Put your fears in perspective

I’m having a helluva Sunday.  My father-in-law’s in the hospital,  it’s 2 degrees out with a wind chill of 40 below, my clothes all smell like latkes, my daughter is having a melt-down, and I screwed up the .xml file for my podcast. The last part reminds me of something—science is hard, and when we step out of our areas of expertise, it’s easy to make some pretty silly mistakes.

If you don’t understand the basics of a subject, it’s easy to form conclusions that seem logical, but these same conclusions seem silly to those who have a deeper understanding of a subject.

With may damned podcast, I’m writing xml files based on templates—little thinking is involved.  I’m looking at other people’s code and inserting my own details, hoping it works.  If I actually understood the syntax of xml files, I could write a correct one based on a solid understanding of the specifics of the subject.

Medicine is one of those areas in which we all feel we should be experts.  After all, we all have a body, and we figure that our bodies follow a logic that we can plainly see—if you prick us, do we not bleed? If you tickle us, do we not laugh? If you poison us, do we not die? It all seems so logical.

Colons are full of poop. Poop is yucky. Therefore, cleaning out a colon is good.

Except that it’s not true. The human body is rather complex, and the study of the aggregate of all human bodies living together (e.g. public health) is more complex still.

Since the world of cult medicine hasn’t bothered to learn real science,  they often rest on what sounds “right”.  Like poop being yucky, this is often based on a sliver of fact that is horribly misused due to ignorance.

One of the more popular canards propagated by cult medicine leaders and their followers is that modern medical care kills.  Rather than exploring what the data are and what they mean in order to find a problem and correct it, they manufacture a problem out of whole cloth and come up with non sequitor solutions.

This little gem, for example, gets it wrong from the start:

As the use of pharmaceuticals drugs has become a leading cause of death in North America, patients want options. Naturopathic Doctors are the only regulated health professionals who study these medications for four years, write licensing examination upon them and whose scope of practice specifically focuses upon these.

First, the data do not point toward “pharmaceuticals drugs” (sic) as a leading cause of death.  The Institute of Medicine found that medical errors in aggregate are a serious problem.  And  Dr. Atwood very effectively debunked the claim that naturopaths have some special insight into pharmacology, refined or otherwise.

Joe Mercola and Gary Null have very long articles on their websites bemoaning the dangers of medicine versus the safety of their own brands of made-up medicine.  They love to make statements like, “It is now  evident that the American medical system is the leading cause of death and injury in the US.”

When cultists cite their terror statistics they leave out a few important facts.  There is no doubt that medical errors, and even medical therapy without errors, can harm.  No one would argue otherwise.  The flip side is, it also helps—a lot.

The document that has fed this conflagration of idiocy is a landmark study by the Institute of Medicine.  One of its findings was that somewhere between 44,000 and 98,000 deaths yearly in the U.S. may be due to medical errors. That’s a lot.  Of course, the lengthy report is somewhat more complex than a single statistic.  Before and after the IOM report, there has been a great deal of research into medical error.  I’ve written a bit about the topic, and the more I study it, the more complexity I see in the problem.  But it’s not an insurmountable complexity.  The question implied by the alties is, “if modern medicine kills so many, why bother with it at all?  Wouldn’t it be safer to do [insert absurdity here]?”

In a word, no.  No, no, NO!  A thousand times NO!

Add A Comment


Dec. 24, 2008 at 11:16 AM

simple smile

Message Friend Invite

Dec. 25, 2008 at 5:40 PM

bow down

Message Friend Invite

Want to leave a comment and join the discussion?

Sign up for CafeMom!

Already a member? Click here to log in

close Cafemom Join now to connect to other members! Connect with Facebook or Sign Up Using Email

Already Joined? LOG IN