Israeli Jews at odds with liberal brethren in US

Hillary Rubin AP – In this photo taken Sunday, Aug. 22, 2010, Hillary Rubin poses for a photograph in her home in Herzeliya, …

JERUSALEM – When Hillary Rubin immigrated from the U.S. to Israel, the granddaughter of Holocaust survivors and descendant of a famed Zionist visionary felt that she had finally arrived in her true home.

But now that religious authorities are questioning the 29-year-old Michigan native's Jewish pedigree and refusing to recognize her marriage, she's having second thoughts.

Rubin is at the center of a deepening rift between the world's two biggest Jewish communities — the American and Israeli. Religious life in Israel is dominated by the strict ultra-Orthodox establishment, which has growing political power and has become increasingly resistant to any inroads by the more liberal movements that predominate among American Jews.

Many Americans — whose faith is seen by the ultra-Orthodox as blurred by intermarriage and fading adherence to tradition — are feeling rejected and unwelcome.

"I feel like I am caught in the middle of these two worlds," said Rubin, who was raised in a liberal Jewish home in a Detroit suburb. "On the one hand I'm far too traditional for American society. On the flip side, I am not religious enough for the rabbinate in Israel."

It's a far cry from the days when American Jews looked to Israel as a source of pride and inspiration and Israel could rely on America's Jews as a source of unconditional moral support and fundraising. With ultra-Orthodox Jews the fastest growing sector in Israel, often holding the balance of power in coalition governments, open strains between the communities are now far more common.

Over the summer, a proposed law that would have consecrated the Orthodox monopoly over conversion in Israel caused an uproar among Diaspora Jews. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu was forced to shelve the bill in hopes of finding a compromise.

Last week, American and Israeli Jewish leaders held a conference in Jerusalem aiming at ironing out their differences. But the closed-door sessions were tense and all sides stuck to their positions, said one participant, American Rabbi Jerome Epstein, of the Conservative movement.

He warned that the conflict could "tear the people apart" if no compromise is found.

"There are a lot of Americans who normally would not get involved in Israeli politics but who are saying, 'What you are doing is delegitimizing me. It is not enough to want my support and want my money, you have to be willing to recognize me as a human being and as a Jew,' and they feel that is not happening," he said.

The two communities are at odds over everything from religious rituals to gender roles. But the issues of marriage and conversion most concretely raise concern among American Jews that they are judged as not Jewish enough for Israel.

The more liberal Reform and Conservative movements, which dominate American Jewish life, are more inclusive toward converts and inter-faith marriages. More than half of American Jews marry outside the faith.

Chelsea Clinton's marriage last summer to Marc Mezvinsky, who is Jewish, showed just how well assimilated U.S. Jews have become. Many American Jews were quietly proud of their homegrown son, who, in a skullcap and prayer shawl, wed the former First Daughter in a ceremony performed by a Reform Rabbi and a Protestant minister.

But to many in Israel, Mezvinsky seemed to break more than a glass at the wedding. The inter-faith ceremony — held on the Sabbath in violation of Jewish law, to boot — encapsulated fears that assimilation is emptying the religion of content and devastating its numbers.

In Israel, despite its secular majority, ultra-Orthodox rabbis strictly govern Jewish practices such as weddings, burials or conversions and only allow them for those who meet Orthodox definitions of a Jew. Israel grants citizenship to any Jew — Reform, Conservative or Orthodox — but once in Israel, many who consider themselves Jewish cannot get married or have a Jewish burial.

Rubin's story shows just how deep the gulf has become.

When she went to the Orthodox rabbinate to register for a marriage certificate, the authorities wouldn't accept the documents she produced or the assurances of her American rabbi that she was indeed Jewish, despite her famous lineage.

The government only recognizes Orthodox marriage and Israel has no civil marriage. So after holding an informal ceremony with a Conservative rabbi, Rubin and her fiance — who is also Jewish — were forced to officially tie the knot in nearby Cyprus to be recognized as married in Israel.

"It terrifies me that this is the direction we are going. This is not a democratic Jewish state. It is becoming a tyrannical Jewish state," said Rubin, whose great-uncle was Nahum Sokolow, one of the pioneers of early 20th century Zionism.

Seth Farber, an Orthodox rabbi and director of a group that helps Israelis navigate the rabbinical bureaucracy, said the threshold for proving one's Judaism has risen alongside the rise in ultra-Orthodox power.

"The biggest danger is that the Israeli body politic will allow the Jewish people to be disenfranchised by giving the ultra-Orthodox all the keys to Jewish identity," he said.

The majority of Israelis appear at odds with their religious authorities.

According to a recent survey conducted for Israel's Ministry of Diaspora Affairs, 63 percent of Israelis believe those converted by non-Orthodox rabbis should be regarded as Jews. The Shiluv pollster questioned a random selection of 507 Israelis and gave a margin of error of 4.5 percentage points.

But Moshe Gafni, an ultra-Orthodox lawmaker whose party is a key coalition member in Netanyahu's government, vows that Israel will not allow what he calls Chelsea Clinton-like weddings and "make-it-up-as-you-go" Judaism.

"We are not saying that someone who is Reform or Conservative is not Jewish. But they can't change the order of things here in Israel," he said. "The average Israeli wants the country to abide by the Jewish tradition ... You can't take the things most sacred to us and tear them to shreds."

Add A Comment


Nov. 2, 2010 at 3:01 AM

WOW! That's ME! I'm surprised to see myself on CafeMOM! I want to add one thing that is missed from this article - when you immigrate to Israel as a Jew, it only takes one Jewish grandparent for the State of Israel to consider you Jewish. When you try to get married, you need proof that your mother is Jewish and, in my case, my maternal grandmother, maternal great grandmother and my maternal great-great grandmother as well. That isn't an easy task when you consider my maternal great grandmother was gassed in Auschwitz-Birkenau. 

Message Friend Invite

Nov. 2, 2010 at 4:38 AM

hi hilly.. nice to meet you!!!!  i thought this story was very interesting giving that so many jewish americans particularly from brooklyn go to isreal.  i wondered how many other people are experiencing the same thing. 

it seems to me that perhaps the recognition of being "jewish" might have something to do with increasing numbers? population? do you think there is truth to that ?

why did you move to isreal? 

Message Friend Invite (Original Poster)

Nov. 3, 2010 at 8:54 AM

That is a really good question. According to the State of Israel, you are Jewish if one of your grandparents is Jewish. That means that if your grandmother or grandfather on either side of your family is Jewish - they count you as a Jew as well and you are entitled to live in Israel, as a Jew, under the "Right of Return" law. 


However, if you're going to get married, you need to visit the Chief Rabbinate - they go by Jewish law (Halacha) which states you are only a Jew if your mother is Jewish. So, you can immigrate to Israel, fight in the Israeli Defense Forces as a Jew but when it comes to getting married or death - you may not be Jewish. 

I moved to Israel because it was the only place on earth I felt at peace with myself and my Jewish identity. Even after all the problems my husband and I went through - my Jewish identity is still in tact - it's never wavered. 

Sometimes being Jewish is a religious experience and sometimes people are Jew - ish... they don't really feel a social responsibility to marry a fellow Jew or help anyone out but they are Jewish by birth. Being Jewish is often a state of mind. I just wrote a blog post about this:

Message Friend Invite

Nov. 5, 2010 at 5:30 AM

so do you still feel the same about being able to live with a jewish identity? are you considered a settler? a zionist?n by those in isreal or outside.  how does that work? and do you consider yourself these things? or what are your thoughts on this issue?

i havent' read your blog yet but i do intend to.  i sometimes get really confused with jewish "state of mind" .. i grew up aroung a lot of reformed jews in new york and then as i got older i moved closer to a really orthodox community... it seems worlds apart.  i also have friends who say they are jewish but don't follow anything relgious.  

i often wonder what exactly makes a jew a jew... how did this "jewish" ethnicy come about.. if it actually exists.  

hopefully you'll be able to answer me. most people haven't really been able to. although recently one friend of mine did a better job at explaining then others.

another question.. if you convert from judaism...are you still a jew if yes. how and if now.. how. 

i know these questions ae loaded... if you can't answer that's ok. but if you can.. im eager to listen 

Message Friend Invite (Original Poster)

Want to leave a comment and join the discussion?

Sign up for CafeMom!

Already a member? Click here to log in