Last night I was watching the news before bed and a report came on about the overwhelming increase of recalled toys this past year.  I was surprised and appalled to hear that the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) which is the agency responsible for testing and researching toys, is extremely understaffed.  And when I say extremely I mean they have one person, that's right ONE person employed to test toys before they hit the shelves.  Well as you can imagine, one employee is not enough, and now because of a lack of resources and authority offered to the CPSC our children suffer.  I found a list of toy brands and there track record for distributing safe toys and I want to pass it along to all you concerned moms. 

Here's what we found.

2003 Toy Report Card

Grades:

A: Excellent, will phase out all PVC products, or products contain no PVC

B: Above average, will phase out some PVC products

C: Average, will eliminate phthalates in toys for children under 3

D: Below average, will eliminate phthalates only in toys intended for the mouth

F: Fail, no policy change

Manufacturer2000 Grade2003 GradeComments
BrioAAKeep up the great work!
ChiccoBAGood effort
Discovery ToysCBCould do better
DisneyDIncNo reply after repeated inquiries
EvenfloDAWhat an improvement - bravo!
First YearsDC+Not living up to potential, but keep trying
GerberAAOne of the stars!
Hasbro/Galoob/PlayschoolDIncNo reply after repeated inquiries
International Playthings (Primetime & Early StartAAOne of the stars!
Kids IIDIncno reply after repeated inquiries
Lamaze Infant DevelopmentBAHope you can eliminate PVC in those last three products quickly
Lego SystemsAAStill waiting for the elimination of PVC in train wiring
Little TykesACMay have been misgraded in 2000, what a disappointment
Manhattan BabyFBIncredible improvement - keep it up!
Mattel/Tyco/Fisher PriceCCCould do a lot better - keep working at it
Munchkin Inc.FDBarely improved - need to work much harder
Safety FirstDIncNo reply after repeated inquiries
SassyAAPlease get rid of that one PVC product - the baby photo book
ShelcoreCDVery disappointing
Tiny LoveAAGreat work!
Warner Bros.FIncNo reply after repeated inquiries

find more information at http://www.greenpeace.org/usa/news/2003-toy-report-card

Also check out Momsrising.com to see what you can do to have your voice heard. 

Add A Comment

Comments:

Be the first to add a comment below.
Want to leave a comment and join the discussion?

Sign up for CafeMom!

Already a member? Click here to log in

Advertisement