Should the Leash-Law apply to 2 year-olds?

  • February 21, 2007 at 10:42 AM by A-TeamMom
  • 17 Comment(s)
  • 226 Total Views

I belong to a little community chatroom and recently someone posted a thread about how much it irritates them when they see children on leashes.  A bunch of people jumped on board with that, saying, "Children aren't pets; they are people.  Putting them on leashes is warped."  Thankfully, several people (including my mom and my girls' mommy-n-me teacher!) were on my side too saying that safety first, sometimes children can't be controlled, some kids are mentally challenged, etc.

Being the mom of twins, I have made a 180 degree turn in my view on child harnesses, especially now that they are darling little backpack harnesses with stuffed animals on the back and the tail is the "leash" (they go for $10 on Target.com!)   I don't think I'll use them every single day like to go to their classroom or to church, but I will definitely use them come time for Disneyland, day long mall trips, etc. 

This is my post:

My twins will be in the toddler stage of life very soon. Although I am looking forward to watching them grow and explore their new freedoms, I am dreading the "one runs this way, the other runs that way" scenario, especially in a very crowded area (Disneyland!) or in dangerous places (busy streets, parking lots).

Now, I have seen some animals behave better than some children! But most people leash their animals to ensure their safety (and to follow local ordinances). But generally speaking, pets are not reasonable beings. They don't think "hey, a car is coming, maybe I won't chase my favorite ball into the street." A 2 year-old doesn't have that ability either.

Honestly, I am very nervous about the toddler stage... I hope my girls will listen to mommy and not bolt into the street for a dropped ball or to chase a kitty. No matter how many times toddlers are told not to run in the street and/or to look both ways, if they are focused on the object of their desire, sometimes all reason is tossed aside. And what if, heaven forbid, one of them goes off with a nice man with candy when you took one moment to dig through your purse for their afternoon snack?

If I only had 1 kid in this phase, I would probably still be on your side saying that the parents should control their kids or hang onto them so that they don't misbehave or run amok. (Actually, I still believe kids shouldn't be running around unattended -- that's just poor parenting!) However, with two active toddlers... I couldn't imagine not using a "leash" in situations where parental control can be easily lost.

That being said, you are right... children are people, not pets. But it's for that reason alone that you absolutely want to ensure your kids' safety in certain situations. No one likes to lose a cat or dog because it ran in front of a car, but the death or harm of a child in a split second can devastate someone's life forever. I'd rather have a few people look at me in disgust than to lose a child unnecessarily.
 

Thoughts?

Tags: child harnesses, leashes, toddlers, control

Comments:

mizzmami
I think your are totally right. I used one for each of my kids and it was safety first for me. I would always get looks and comments about it but I didn't care I would rather get insulted then loose a child in any case.

mizzmami Feb. 21, 2007 at 10:45 AM

momio...
I completely agree with you. Safety first!

momiofcristina Feb. 21, 2007 at 10:46 AM

Hendr...
i use to be hugely anti-lease, because i thought it was a cope out for partents. HA, my baby is only 8 months and i can already tell that there may be times when those cute monkey backpack leases will be necessary (zoo, mall, amusement parks, libraries). hes extremely curious and alert and active! how horrible would it be if he was hurt due to his curiosities? it may not be for everyone, but i completely agree with you!

HendrixandMama Feb. 21, 2007 at 11:09 AM

MamaWen
Being a mom of twins... I totally agree. My response to people who comment about me putting my kids on a leash, "Why would you protect your animal with a leash and not your child?" In crowded places you need that extra care to make sure your child is safe. Not only so you don't have to worry about them running away in opposite directions, but it also takes away the possibility of being kidnapped. I say, if you love your kids, protect them every way possible when in a crowded situation. Even when I was 12 my mom would have me hold on to her sweater if we were somewhere with lots of people. You just don't want to get seperated, and who knows what else.

MamaWen Feb. 21, 2007 at 3:06 PM

Onepl...
I COMPLETELY agree with you!  I used the leash on my son when he was little (I think he still needs it sometimes LOL) and we were in a crowded place.  It defiantly is a safety issue.  With my twins, I have to be honest we don't go out to crowded places that often, but when we do.  I use the leash.  I could care less what people have to say about it.   I know that my children are safe and within arms reach at all times and that is all the matters to me. 

OneplusTwins Mar. 4, 2007 at 1:53 PM

Bipol...
I used to be anti-leash little people.  I used to make comments loud enough as those parents walked by that it was terrible and how awful it must be to HAVE to watch your child.  I used to think that seeing those harnesses (the old ones) on those kids were the worst things ever invented.  UNTIL I HAD A KID THAT NEEDED ONE!!!  I'll tell you what, I'd like to shake that person's hand that invented that little piece of magic and ask them if they have anything in industrial strength leather with locks that are voice activated and have parental retinal scanners!!!!

BipolarCorner Mar. 18, 2007 at 11:26 PM

ingri...
I am all for the leash. Having 3 kids, ages 6, 4 and almost 2... plus the twins on the way... when I go out with them... one is bound to go crazy and go of runing. So I prefere to be looked at awfully by people than to loose one of my children.  I don't have 3 leaches (hahaha like walking dogs) but I do have one for the toddler which loooooves to hide under the racks of clothes, and change from one aisle to another with out consulting with me...: )  sooo, if I can keep track of one by means of a leash, and the other two by means of.....hmmmm let me think.... well any other mean.. its worth it for me.

ingrid4twins May. 18, 2007 at 7:30 PM

steph...
I totally agree with you. i was never really against it cause i have seen kids with those backpacks.

stephanie021 Aug. 23, 2007 at 11:16 AM

t_06_...
In this day and time when kids are being abducted by perverts and even killed, I'm a strong believer in safety first. I just went to Babies R Us and bought each one of my twins a harness or leash whatever you want to call it.  They have two really cute designs at Babies R Us, we got a backpack for our son, it goes on and wraps around his waste...we got a purse for our daughter, it goes on across her chest and wraps around her waste. They were 14.99 each in Kentucky....

t_06_twins Nov. 21, 2007 at 12:12 AM

Beagles
i wouldn't even think of having a leash on your child is cruel!  my son loves to run and take off especially at Disneyland and boy does he run FAST!!!  he has a monkey backpack and the leash is the monkeys tail, bought it at target.  I love this thing, i feel safe when it's on him.  It's so i can keep him in my sight and maybe stop him from getting into something dangerous!  it only takes a second to lose your child, specially in a crowd, with all those sickos out there nowadays, people snatching children, there's no way in hell i would let him run lose (especially at Disneyland) who in the hell would think that a leash is "cruel"  i just don't get it.  having a leash is SMART and SAFE

Beagles Feb. 12, 2008 at 2:42 AM

Want to leave a comment and join the discussion?

Click here to register for CafeMom

Already a member?Click here to log in

© 2008 CMI Marketing, Inc. All rights reserved.